Search results

  1. E

    Texas synagogue hostage crisis for Afia Siddiqui release, suspect is dead

    Maybe this is another case of entrapment for which these Western, especially American agencies, are infamous. They groom a socially estranged or a cognitively challenged individual to commit a crime. For this specific incident, they could achieve many goals. a) Show the world how the world...
  2. E

    عدت میں نکاح، طاہر اشرفی کے لاہور ہائیکورٹ کے فیصلے پر اعتراضات

    Islamic guidelines for marital relationships among Muslims are not binding on non-Muslims.
  3. E

    عدت میں نکاح، طاہر اشرفی کے لاہور ہائیکورٹ کے فیصلے پر اعتراضات

    Islamic guidelines are there to protect human beings and not to agonize them; and they are deeper in their meaning and function then we usually perceive. Besides its physiological aspect Islam also takes in consideration the psychological underpinnings of previously intimate relationships...
  4. E

    Rising Cause Of Atheism In Pakistan

    Saying a person calling it mental gymnastic to avoid tackling the questions. Got it. I would engage with you every time you set out to to be critical towards Hadeeth. But Hadith is not Quran right. You haven't read all the Hadith either. Right? And I wouldn't tell the Athiest to read all the...
  5. E

    Rising Cause Of Atheism In Pakistan

    Yeas, I would suggest that next time don't mention reading Bukhari from cover to cover with these ideas of yours. It's not a good look for you when someone listens to your lack of depth on the understanding of Hadith.
  6. E

    Rising Cause Of Atheism In Pakistan

    Yes, present no resonable arugument but call it mental gymnastics because it's beyond your mental capacity and reasoning ability. I read it and waisted my few seconds. I wish I had listened to my intuition knowing that it would be nothing but another hot air nonsense. Yet I still took time to...
  7. E

    Rising Cause Of Atheism In Pakistan

    Citizen X What you keep calling my mental gymnastic is either your inability to connect simple dots or construct some better arguments. The Ahadeeth you mentioned as problematic would not be problematic if you would have bothered to read the work of Hadith scholars about the discussion of...
  8. E

    Rising Cause Of Atheism In Pakistan

    Not a Hadith. common sense in any state. Such people would be declared criminals in any state Including a state which follows Quran and Hadith. People read the verse of Quran on the punishment of murder and could carry it on individualy. No Hadith needed there. Muslim Jurists who are experts of...
  9. E

    Rising Cause Of Atheism In Pakistan

    Before I answer that, how do you pray? Exactly the point. Use your mind beyond your limited prejudice. Why a prophet, why not just give the book, so people can read and decide. Did you read the understand of this Aya? Give me the meaning and then I will satisfy your little bewildering mind...
  10. E

    Rising Cause Of Atheism In Pakistan

    Man, do you have some reading and comprehension issues? Didn't I say that act of Punishment is a State affair and need a formal deliberation from state authorized Jurists and scholars. Individuals can't take any law in their own hand or kill a person under any allegations. Don't Hadith...
  11. E

    Rising Cause Of Atheism In Pakistan

    Allah knows your intentions behind your actions. Blasphemy law or any communal actions' example is ill-suited in this manner. It's a matter of Islamic Jurisprudence which requires serious deliberation.
  12. E

    Rising Cause Of Atheism In Pakistan

    How do you know that he stopped people. It's not in the Quran You are right Quran is a complete book. So Allah could have send an angel with a book and distribute among people. Then Why should Allah needed a human being to deliver a message? To show that this human (the prophet) would become a...
  13. E

    Rising Cause Of Atheism In Pakistan

    If I give you the answer how would it change the discussion? "and the number keeps growing daily" Where did you get this information from?
  14. E

    Rising Cause Of Atheism In Pakistan

    Hadith is a part of the source of Deen. Our prophet's life is the ultimate exegisis of Quran. We can't even pray 5 times without that.
  15. E

    Rising Cause Of Atheism In Pakistan

    This only goes to show that how much hard work they did to check the authenticity. Also negates your idea of using currency if many of it is fake. People would not mind to find one real diamond to have among hundred fake ones.
  16. E

    Rising Cause Of Atheism In Pakistan

    And how do you know that it isn't the case with Koran. Because that is what the critics of Islam claims about Koran.
  17. E

    Rising Cause Of Atheism In Pakistan

    Actually we can verify what Jinnah actually said through different recorded sources. The difference is either of personal biases or interpretation. That Beduan culture was famous for its ability of oral transmission of literary work even before Islam. That's why the scholars who collected this...
  18. E

    Rising Cause Of Atheism In Pakistan

    I want you to prove me that 99 % of Ahadeeth in prominent Ahadeeth books are not valid.
  19. E

    Rising Cause Of Atheism In Pakistan

    Non sensical Hadith? The words of the Prophet ?