Are women safe in India?

simple_and_peacefull

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)

[video]http://aje.me/RO0dWu[/video]

The gang-rape of a medical student on a moving bus last week in New Delhi has triggered mass protests on the streets of India, with calls for change and justice for a young woman.

She was raped for about an hour and thrown out of the bus. She is recovering in the intensive care unit after undergoing multiple surgeries. Her injuries were so bad that she was only recently able to give a statement to the Indian authorities.
The 23-year-old told police six men took turns sexually assaulting her. The suspects allegedly used a metal rod to assault the victim and her friend.

Angry Indians are hitting the streets, defying a ban on mass demonstrations. Police have been using tear gas and water cannon against the protesters.

So, just how widespread a problem is sexual abuse against women in India?

There are reports that suggest that in India, a woman is raped every 20 minutes.

More than 24,000 rape cases in the country were reported last year alone, of which 570 were reported in the Indian capital, where already this year 635 rape cases have been registered.
The legal news service Trust Law says India is the worst country in the G20 to be a woman. It says women and girls continue to be sold, married off at a young age, exploited and abused as domestic slaves.

The number of crimes recorded against women, including kidnapping, abduction, and human trafficking exceeds 2.5 million.

Many activists say Indians are protesting against what they say is a culture of impunity.
There are 40,000 pending rape cases in the country and survivors have to wait years for their cases to be heard even then the conviction rate is just 34.6 percent according to the National Crimes Record Bureau.

The Indian Penal Code lists punishments of up to life behind bars, but those convicted are often let off after serving a short sentence.

Undercover reporters in India gathered evidence of how the police in the Delhi region view rape survivors. The investigation published by the Indian weekly Tehelka exposed how the system often blames the survivors.

Senior police officers were caught on hidden camera talking about survivors, saying: "She asked for it; "It's all about money"; "They have made it a business"; "It's consensual most of the time".

Seventeen officers in over a dozen police stations were caught on spy cameras blaming everything from revealing clothes to having boyfriends or going to pubs as the main reasons for rape.

The investigators came to the conclusion that the officers encountered do not fulfil the basic standard of policing, which requires investigating a case without any cultural, class or gender bias.

In this episode, Inside Story discusses if women are safe in India.

Joining the discussion, with presenter Hazem Sika, are guests: Kavita Krishnan, the secretary of the All-India Progressive Women's Association; Rajeev Aswathi, a New Delhi high court lawyer who has previously represented rape survivors; and Lawrence Saez, a professor of political economy at the School of Oriental and African Studies, and the author of New Dimensions of Politics in India: The United Progressive Alliance in Power.
"This case has alerted people to the problem primarily because the victim was a middle-class student and the alleged rapists are people who migrated to the city so there's an element of social class struggle. But rape is sadly quite common in the villages, sometimes by the police and by people who are wealthy against people who are very poor, and they escape with impunity."
Lawrence Saez, a professor of political economy

Rape capitals of the world in 2010:

  • South Africa it has one of the highest rates, with 277,000 reported cases. The same year a survey by the Medical Research Council found that one in four men admitted to raping someone
  • United States more than 84,000 rape cases were reported. Criminals face life behind bars, and in some states, castration is an option
  • India reported a little more than 22,000 cases
  • United Kingdom 16,000 cases were reported. A suspect found guilty, faces a maximum conviction of life in prison
  • Mexico nearly 15,000 cases were reported. In some parts of the country, penalties may consist of a few hours in jail, or minor fines
  • Germany counts the highest number of reported rape cases in Europe, just under 8,000
  • Russia almost 5,000 cases were reported, and the crime holds a punishment of 4 -10 years in jail
Source:Al Jazeera
 

Heart

Councller (250+ posts)
India: Death Penalty for Rapists

The 23-year-old physiotherapy student, who was gang-raped and assaulted on a moving bus on Dec. 16, is still battling for her life. This gory crime has sparked national outrage and turned Delhi into a war zone with disparate groups agitating against the horrific incident. Succumbing to the tremendous public pressure for deterrent laws against rape, the government is seeking a review of the present laws so as to provide for speedier justice and enhanced punishment in cases of aggravated sexual assault. At present, the maximum punishment for a rape convict is life imprisonment but now the government is seriously considering the death penalty in the rarest of the rare cases of rape.

The question that comes to mind is why everyone has joined the chorus of applying that repressive draconian punishment which was once the aspect of the broader campaign against Islamic repressive draconian rule. I express my deep distress over the recent shocking event but caution that though the death penalty over the ghastly incident is justified but mere punishment is no solution. If Islam gives very harsh punishments for crimes like that it also dictates that women are fully covered in public realm.


After looking at the recent protests it appears that the time has come to debate the place of the veil in the modern secular society. There is a whole psychology behind this veil. It prohibits adultery, secret affairs, illegitimate children, rapes and it gives a big no" signal to all those people who have any kind of evil in their hearts.


We need to have a public debate over covered or uncovered? Whether women dressed in handkerchief skirts and bikini blouses were appropriate role models?


The irony is that the images of sleek, bare women in Indian and Western popular media also represent a major offensive against the health of women and girls. Even if we take religion out of the debate, still we may see that Western values and sexually expressive culture put the physical and emotional health of future generations at stake all over the world. Israrul Haque, Jeddah

http://www.arabnews.com/death-penalty-rapists
 

WatanDost

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Re: India: Death Penalty for Rapists

Brother @ Heart ,

AAJ nahi tow KAL, es INSANIAT ki Nijaat issi main hai kai,
ISLAAM kay LAW ko AS it IS implement karain,

Kioon kai
"Qassas main ZINDAGI hai" As per Quran<Mafhoom>


 

WatanDost

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
AAJ nahi tow KAL, es INSANIAT ki Nijaat issi main hai kai,
ISLAAM kay LAW ko AS it IS implement karain,

Kioon kai
"Qassas main ZINDAGI hai" As per Quran <Mafhoom>​
 

Believer12

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Here in the safe countries situation is getting worst. last year they arrested a six members group based on ill legal kurdish asylum seekers.they were involved in very serious and horrible gang rape cases.
Somali Muslims are selling narcotics. their activities are effecting other good Muslims.
Same Taliban mafia in Pakistan is a big hurdle in the progress of Islam.
 

geek04

Politcal Worker (100+ posts)
Re: India: Death Penalty for Rapists

Brother @ Heart ,

AAJ nahi tow KAL, es INSANIAT ki Nijaat issi main hai kai,
ISLAAM kay LAW ko AS it IS implement karain,

Kioon kai
"Qassas main ZINDAGI hai" As per Quran<Mafhoom>



Any religion is not a solution to any social problem. It can be controlled by implementing strict rules and tight administration.
 

modern.fakir

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Re: India: Death Penalty for Rapists

Islam is not a religion BUT a way of life....first read up about it and then comment !(bigsmile)

Any religion is not a solution to any social problem. It can be controlled by implementing strict rules and tight administration.
 

alimohsan52

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
In my point of view this is ridiculous to target India in this manner. Rather than act like opportunists on this sensitive matter we should engage in initiatives which are mutually beneficial for both sides and help to reduce problems in both our countries.
 

Imranpak

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Re: India: Death Penalty for Rapists

As long as Islam believes in conversion, it cannot be a described a way of life.

Man should be free to convert to any "way of life" or leave religion altogether. Many people who leave Islam are answerable to Allah not me. Every faith has converts and apostates but yes Islam is a missionary faith yet we don't stop non-Muslim's from preaching either.
 

lurker

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Islam couldn't stop Pakistani Amry from raping Bangladeshi women. Islam couldn't even stop the break up of Bangladesh. Islam can't even stop the Syrian war. Islam is responsible for the Taliban killing their own Muslims. Islam didn't stop the demolition of Janat-ul-Baqi. Islam didn't stop Karbala. Islam cannot re-take jerusalem. Islam cannot overthrow Saudi monarchy and you cannot re-take the Kabah. If Islam is the glue that binds us, then it looks like its made in China. :P

Islam is just another popular religion. And I am saying this while I am a muslim. Other muslims cannot fathom this idea. lol.
 
Last edited:

deltaforce

Senator (1k+ posts)
Re: India: Death Penalty for Rapists

Man should be free to convert to any "way of life" or leave religion altogether. Many people who leave Islam are answerable to Allah not me. Every faith has converts and apostates but yes Islam is a missionary faith yet we don't stop non-Muslim's from preaching either.


that is why such people are dispatched or killed to go to allah and answer him for the sins committed . by greats like mumtaj kadri saheb or burnt by some unruly insane mob.
 

modern.fakir

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Re: India: Death Penalty for Rapists

Again the problem is lack of understanding of Islam. Their is no conversion in Islam BUT only reversion for those who wish to return to the right path. IN a 1000 year rule over India the Hindus are still a majority. This is the biggest proof of Islams just rule.



As long as Islam believes in conversion, it cannot be a described a way of life.
 

geek04

Politcal Worker (100+ posts)
Re: India: Death Penalty for Rapists

Islam is not a religion BUT a way of life....first read up about it and then comment !(bigsmile)

Oh.. now the word "religion" is a offence to Islam?? Thanks for the senseless suggestion.
 

modern.fakir

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Re: India: Death Penalty for Rapists

Mumtaz Qadri acted against Blasphemy you idiot !...First go an learn the difference between blasphemy and preaching ..(bigsmile)

that is why such people are dispatched or killed to go to allah and answer him for the sins committed . by greats like mumtaj kadri saheb or burnt by some unruly insane mob.
 

modern.fakir

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Re: India: Death Penalty for Rapists

Do you need new glasses geek ?(bigsmile) ... I said its not a religion but a full way off life ?....are you implying things on your own here ?(bigsmile)

Oh.. now the word "religion" is a offence to Islam?? Thanks for the senseless suggestion.
 

modern.fakir

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Lurker, we are talking about Muslims here ...not people who have no faith and are maybe wearing the Garb of a Muslim. Like you said ..."nothing changes" ....Then why this useless rant ??:lol:

Islam couldn't stop Pakistani Amry from raping Bangladeshi women. Islam couldn't even stop the break up of Bangladesh. Islam can't even stop the Syrian war. Islam is responsible for the Taliban killing their own Muslims. Islam didn't stop the demolition of Janat-ul-Baqi. Islam didn't stop Karbala. Islam cannot re-take jerusalem. Islam cannot overthrow Saudi monarchy and you cannot re-take the Kabah. If Islam is the glue that binds us, then it looks like its made in China. :P

Islam is just another popular religion. And I am saying this while I am a muslim. Other muslims cannot fathom this idea. lol.
 

geek04

Politcal Worker (100+ posts)
Re: India: Death Penalty for Rapists

Do you need new glasses geek ?(bigsmile) ... I said its not a religion but a full way off life ?....are you implying things on your own here ?(bigsmile)

You said that before calling Islam as is one of the worlds religion I should read about it. Before commenting. Why?

Also, every devotee says the same for every religion that it is a way of life. You mean to say the Talibani got their way of life from Islam? Please..