Collection, Writing an Accreditation of Hadith..

عؔلی خان

MPA (400+ posts)
Someone who considers that gorilla hijab a scholar .............................. ?

I consider myself just an ordinary Muslim and student of Deen-e-Islam.

Having said that if one compares you (i.e. your profile) with Mohammed Hijab, one finds out that you have no professional or academic credentials whatsoever to show except someone behind an anonymous and random id posting walls of text, rantings, innuendos, mocking others, and calling names to others on a Public Forum like siasat.pk hoping that one will fall for his tattle.

Here is a glimpse of Mohammed Hijab's profile posted on one of the websites:

Mohammed Hijab is an author, comparative-religionist, and philosopher of religion. He is the co-founder of Sapience Institute and is a researcher and instructor for the organization. He has a BA in Politics and a master’s degree in History. He has also acquired a second master’s in Islamic Studies from the School of Oriental and African Studies. Hijab has also completed a third master’s degree in Applied Theology from the University of Oxford where he focussed on the Philosophy of Religion in applied settings. Hijab is now doing his Ph.D. in Philosophy of Religion on the Contingency Argument for God’s existence.

In addition, Hijab has undergone formal training in Islamic studies, with a focus on the Qur’an, Prophetic traditions, and legal reasoning. Hijab has completed Islamic seminary courses and been given formal permission to relay Islamic knowledge on selected Islamic fields. Hijab is one of the very few Muslim public figures who deal comparatively with political, philosophical, and theological issues and as such has amassed a following of many subscribers on YouTube in English and Arabic.


Mohammed Hijab, albeit not a full scholar yet but an ordinary Muslim like myself, routinely debates Quranists and others (e.g. David Wood) on Social Media and his YouTube Chanel has garnered more than half a million subscribers.

For example, "Mohammed Hijab vs. David Wood | Tawheed vs. Trinity", a debate between Mohammed Hijab and David Wood, has been seen by almost 3 million people on YouTube:


And yet here you are ashamed of even posting your real name or making it abundantly clear to others to whom you exactly follow without naming the names of your scholars.

Your holier-than-thou attitude won't get you that far.
 
Last edited:

Wake up Pak

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
Apart from reading ahadith books.. there are ahadith written in almost every tafseer.. bcz without ahadith.. scholars are unable to explain the vrs... n if thy do.. tht will b thr persnl views.. which normally will not b accepted.
Who gave you this idea that without hadeeth you can not explain the Quran?
I believe I discussed it before that, hadeeth only interpreted less than 30% of the Quran, and that too with contradictions.
Here is what Allah says.


25_33.png


25:33 And they do not come to you with an argument except that We bring you the truth and the best (TAFSEER) explanation.
(TAFSEER, the explanation of the Qur'an from within itself)
 

Citizen X

President (40k+ posts)
I consider myself just an ordinary Muslim and student of Deen-e-Islam.

Having said that if one compares you (i.e. your profile) with Mohammed Hijab, one finds out that you have no professional or academic credentials whatsoever to show except someone behind an anonymous and random id posting walls of text, rantings, innuendos, mocking others, and calling names to others on a Public Forum like siasat.pk hoping that one will fall for his tattle.

Here is a glimpse of Mohammed Hijab's profile posted on one of the websites:

Mohammed Hijab is an author, comparative-religionist, and philosopher of religion. He is the co-founder of Sapience Institute and is a researcher and instructor for the organization. He has a BA in Politics and a master’s degree in History. He has also acquired a second master’s in Islamic Studies from the School of Oriental and African Studies. Hijab has also completed a third master’s degree in Applied Theology from the University of Oxford where he focussed on the Philosophy of Religion in applied settings. Hijab is now doing his Ph.D. in Philosophy of Religion on the Contingency Argument for God’s existence.

In addition, Hijab has undergone formal training in Islamic studies, with a focus on the Qur’an, Prophetic traditions, and legal reasoning. Hijab has completed Islamic seminary courses and been given formal permission to relay Islamic knowledge on selected Islamic fields. Hijab is one of the very few Muslim public figures who deal comparatively with political, philosophical, and theological issues and as such has amassed a following of many subscribers on YouTube in English and Arabic.


Mohammed Hijab, albeit not a full scholar yet but an ordinary Muslim like myself, routinely debates Quranists and others (e.g. David Wood) on Social Media and his YouTube Chanel has garnered more than half a million subscribers.

For example, "Mohammed Hijab vs. David Wood | Tawheed vs. Trinity", a debate between Mohammed Hijab and David Wood, has been seen by almost 3 million people on YouTube:


And yet here you are ashamed of even posting your real name or making it abundantly clear to others to whom you exactly follow without naming the names of your scholars.

Your holier-than-thou attitude won't get you that far.
Am I supposed to be impressed by that gorilla's CV?
 

Citizen X

President (40k+ posts)
Who gave you this idea that without hadeeth you can not explain the Quran?
I believe I discussed it before that, hadeeth only interpreted less than 30% of the Quran, and that too with contradictions.
Here is what Allah says.


25_33.png


25:33 And they do not come to you with an argument except that We bring you the truth and the best (TAFSEER) explanation.
(TAFSEER, the explanation of the Qur'an from within itself)
These are the same bhaand moulvis who say, Quran tarjumay ke saath matt pardo, gunnah millay ga. So it has been drilled into these peoples head that the Quran is incomplete without the hadith, which in itself is a total contradiction of what the Quran says about itself.
 

عؔلی خان

MPA (400+ posts)
You must think very highly of yourself if you think I'm even remotely trying to impress you or anyone else from the takfeer factory.

Ditto!

I dare you to name the names of your scholars or the persons to whom you follow or get your knowledge from or influenced from to let others see to whom you exactly follow without claiming that you are knowledgeable enough of the Arabic language and other tenants of Islam that you don't even need to learn from anybody else.
 
Last edited:

jani1

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
I consider myself just an ordinary Muslim and student of Deen-e-Islam.

Having said that if one compares you (i.e. your profile) with Mohammed Hijab, one finds out that you have no professional or academic credentials whatsoever to show except someone behind an anonymous and random id posting walls of text, rantings, innuendos, mocking others, and calling names to others on a Public Forum like siasat.pk hoping that one will fall for his tattle.

Here is a glimpse of Mohammed Hijab's profile posted on one of the websites:

Mohammed Hijab is an author, comparative-religionist, and philosopher of religion. He is the co-founder of Sapience Institute and is a researcher and instructor for the organization. He has a BA in Politics and a master’s degree in History. He has also acquired a second master’s in Islamic Studies from the School of Oriental and African Studies. Hijab has also completed a third master’s degree in Applied Theology from the University of Oxford where he focussed on the Philosophy of Religion in applied settings. Hijab is now doing his Ph.D. in Philosophy of Religion on the Contingency Argument for God’s existence.

In addition, Hijab has undergone formal training in Islamic studies, with a focus on the Qur’an, Prophetic traditions, and legal reasoning. Hijab has completed Islamic seminary courses and been given formal permission to relay Islamic knowledge on selected Islamic fields. Hijab is one of the very few Muslim public figures who deal comparatively with political, philosophical, and theological issues and as such has amassed a following of many subscribers on YouTube in English and Arabic.


Mohammed Hijab, albeit not a full scholar yet but an ordinary Muslim like myself, routinely debates Quranists and others (e.g. David Wood) on Social Media and his YouTube Chanel has garnered more than half a million subscribers.

For example, "Mohammed Hijab vs. David Wood | Tawheed vs. Trinity", a debate between Mohammed Hijab and David Wood, has been seen by almost 3 million people on YouTube:


And yet here you are ashamed of even posting your real name or making it abundantly clear to others to whom you exactly follow without naming the names of your scholars.

Your holier-than-thou attitude won't get you that far.
Impressive masha Allah....
I never hv thought tht his knowledge n qualification is more thn an ordinary mufti...
but he seems to be well qualified.
 

jani1

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Salah, zakah, fast, haj what? Is there suppose to be a question in there?
OK... got it.. U r not only n ignorant but also a gajni... check my posts in this thread, whr I asked u if u blv in Salah, zakah, fast, haj..
how many times do u pray... or a muslim should pray..
do u fast in ramadan..
do u pay zakat...
ever planned to go to makkah to perform ur haj...?
 

jani1

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Ditto!

I dare you to name the names of your scholars or the persons to whom you follow or get your knowledge from to let others see to whom you exactly follow without claiming that you are knowledgeable enough of the Arabic language and other tenants of Islam that you don't even need to learn from anybody else.
not only citizen xtra but his scholar also shy to share his real name bcz he was charged with extreme pornography (child porn ) in Birmingham ...


allow m to show u his scholar... abu layth. (not his real name)




M. Hijab's views on this clown ?



a must watch ?

 
Last edited:

jani1

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Who gave you this idea that without hadeeth you can not explain the Quran?
I believe I discussed it before that, hadeeth only interpreted less than 30% of the Quran, and that too with contradictions.
what u talking about ?
dont u think even 1 % of the Quran should not be left unexplained.. n here u r admitting around 30 % of the Quran is explained by ahadith..
tht means ahadith aren't irrelevant after all ...
 

jani1

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
These are the same bhaand moulvis who say, Quran tarjumay ke saath matt pardo, gunnah millay ga.
who ever says tht.. I condemn thm ..
u r doing it deliberately or u r a real gajni... I'v always emphasized on reading Quran with translation n tafseer ...
 
Last edited:

Wake up Pak

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
what u talking about ?
dont u think even 1 % of the Quran should not be left unexplained.. n here u r admitting around 30 % of the Quran is explained by ahadith..
tht means ahadith aren't irrelevant after all ...
What are you talking about? Don't you know how to read?
 
Last edited:

Citizen X

President (40k+ posts)