Govt allows costly wheat import

Okara

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
Sir 80% items sir not only sugar or Wheat.

Food items.

They allowed everything to import like PMLN did.
Please check your response at #8
First time in history Pakistan to import 80% wheat ever in Pakistan. This is a shame and incompetence that a honest person is worse than criminal in Pakistan. This is a shame and shocking.
Is this not your quote?
 

Doom1111

Minister (2k+ posts)
Please check your response at #8

Is this not your quote?
Wrong Statement by me. I apologize what i meant by all food items not only Wheat or Sugar.

We are more importing food in quantity this 4 months than we did in PMLN. Month by Month comparison.
 

Okara

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
Wrong Statement by me. I apologize what i meant by all food items not only Wheat or Sugar.

We are more importing food in quantity this 4 months than we did in PMLN. Month by Month comparison.
Are u saying 80% is import while 20% is local produce for all food items?
Now can you share how much we were importing per year in PMLN and now in PTI times. Lets compare 2017 with 2020 despite we hit Locust attack in 2020.
 

Doom1111

Minister (2k+ posts)
Are u saying 80% is import while 20% is local produce for all food items?
Now can you share how much we were importing per year in PMLN and now in PTI times. Lets compare 2017 with 2020 despite we hit Locust attack in 2020.
Less than PMLN sir.

PTI sir

 

Doom1111

Minister (2k+ posts)
On note sir that 2017-2018 food prices was expensive and 2020 food item cheaper. You can check your self out.

The biggest blunder PTI did it was that made JKT it's enemy ,where he could have Pakistan from importing wheat and sugar.
 

Okara

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
Less than PMLN sir.

PTI sir

Please read both news first and then we will discuss. One news is talking about food imports and other trade deficit in billions.
 

Terminator;

Minister (2k+ posts)
ISLAMABAD:
The government on Thursday allowed importing wheat at $383.50 per metric ton or Rs65 per kilogram – the highest price ever paid by the country – but scrapped a sugar import tender due to the same reason.

The Economic Coordination Committee (ECC) of the cabinet, which took these decisions, also cleared the scaled-back Kamyab Pakistan Programme amid few committee members’ concerns over missing some critical details from the summary.

Against the original plan of Rs815 billion programme for two years, the finance ministry presented Rs228 billion programme for fiscal year 2021-22 and 2022-23 –the last two years of the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) government. The subsidies were shown at Rs37 billion to give loans to just one million borrowers.

Wheat import

“The ECC accorded approval for the lowest bid received for award of fourth international wheat tender for the FY 2021-22 to import 120,000 MT of wheat,” the Ministry of Finance stated after the ECC meeting.

A senior government official told The Express Tribune that the lowest bid was $383.50 per metric ton or Rs65 per kg at today’s exchange rate. The last tender had been signed at $356 per ton or Rs61 per kg. The 40kg import price will be roughly Rs2,600, which is far higher than the release price of Rs1,950 that Prime Minister Imran Khan approved for issuing wheat to flour mills.

The federal government has decided to import four million metric tons of wheat to meet domestic shortfall and build some strategic reserves. However, so far, all four tenders have remained under subscribed and prices ranged from $244 of first tender to roughly $384 per metric ton of the latest tender.

The special assistant to the prime minister on national food security claimed on Wednesday that except the poorest people everyone else would get wheat flour at Rs55 per kg. But at Rs65 wheat price, the government will have to give huge subsidies.

Sugar import

The ECC approved scrapping a 50,000 metric tons sugar import tender after a Geneva-based bidder gave $670 per metric ton price, which was the highest price or could have cost per kg at Rs113. The government had approved the last tender for 200,000 metric tons of sugar import at around $637 per metric tons that translated into Rs106 per kilogram.

Read More: ECC may give nod to 40,000 tons wheat purchase

Instead, the ECC directed that to issue fresh three separate tenders of 50,000 metric tons each so that there is more participation and increased competition when international prices fall down.

An official of the Ministry of Industries said that sufficient sugar stocks of 715,000 metric tons were available in the country. In addition to that, 200,000 metric imported sugar was being loaded in ships that will reach Pakistan soon.

The federal government had decided to import 600,000 metric tons of sugar, out of which approval for 300,000 metric tons import has already been given.

The ECC emphasised to ensure a smooth supply of sugar throughout the country and directed to initiate crushing by sugar mills in the beginning of November, 2021 as done last year, said the finance ministry.

Kamyab Pakistan Programme

The Finance Division presented an updated summary regarding Kamyab Pakistan Program (KPP) before ECC on Thursday, according to the press release.

A senior finance ministry official said that the government has now reduced the plan to just Rs90 billion loans to be disbursed among 301,500 borrowers in this fiscal year and another Rs138 billion in next fiscal year among over 738,000 borrowers. The subsidies in the first year were Rs5.6 billion and Rs31.4 billion in the second year, he added.

A participant of the meeting said that the finance ministry did not have the data about the numbers of districts that it had finally picked for targeting, therefore, the amount of subsidies, loans and beneficiaries were tentative and will be firmed up further.

Finance Minister Shaukat Tarin had vowed to launch the largest-ever program in the history of Pakistan to disburse interest-free to cheapest loans among 30 million people in three years. However, his ambitions were watered down by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the bureaucracy of the finance ministry.

The finance ministry handout stated that the “programme has been streamlined in consultation with stakeholders to disburse microcredit for uplifting marginalised segments of the society.”

Under the first three components, micro-loans shall be disbursed amongst eligible persons registered with Ehsaas Data through National Socio-Economic Registry (NSER) who have family income of up to Rs50,000 per month.

Published in The Express Tribune, September 24th, 2021.
بھڑوا لیگ اپنے لفافی اخباروں میں جھوٹی خبریں چھپواتے ہیں،، اور پھر مُودے کنجر کے شاگرد درباری،، اور تم جیسے کیڑے مکوڑےپٹواری حرامزادے، اُسکو مدھانی میں ڈال کر کانجی، یا لسّی کی شکل دیکر بیچتے کی کوشش کرتے ہیں

ایک باپ 'اپنے پٹواری پُتر کو ڈانٹ پلاتے ہوئے ۔ ۔ ۔
بہن چود ،،،،، دیانت داری کر،،حلال دی کھا

 

Doom1111

Minister (2k+ posts)
Please read both news first and then we will discuss. One news is talking about food imports and other trade deficit in billions.
Sir
PTI

"Pakistan spent over $8 billion on import of edible items in the last financial year."

PMLN
"Food import increased to 6.185 billion dollar in 2017-2018"
 

s.shahid

MPA (400+ posts)
Total food item consumption i meant.
Are u saying 80% is import while 20% is local produce for all food items?
Now can you share how much we were importing per year in PMLN and now in PTI times. Lets compare 2017 with 2020 despite we hit Locust attack in 2020.
Okara, the number was quoted in Josh-e-khitabat. For an actual comparison of 2017 to 2021, prices in international market at that time and current prices needs to be considered, just a numerical comparison serves no purpose, because you can be importing less in quantity yet your import bill can be higher due to higher commodity price, and in recent times prices in international markets has increased unprecedentedly.

To Despardo, whilst in principal I agree with you that Pakistan should have restricted imports of non-essential items, specially in past few months, as it has increased CAD considerably and has put pressure on BOP, and brining in Tarin as FM was a mistake, as gains for past 3 years is fast eroding, though now steps are being taken to avert CAD and BOP crisis. However, for reasons best known to you, you seems to through in figure out of nowhere and which are factually incorrect (likes this 80% wheat or even 80% food import and even before SBP put out actual figures you quoted reserves has decreased by 400m, when in fact they went up by $2.5bn), that only damages your credibility, even when you have a valid point to prove. Probably time to take a little break..........
 

Doom1111

Minister (2k+ posts)
Okara, the number was quoted in Josh-e-khitabat. For an actual comparison of 2017 to 2021, prices in international market at that time and current prices needs to be considered, just a numerical comparison serves no purpose, because you can be importing less in quantity yet your import bill can be higher due to higher commodity price, and in recent times prices in international markets has increased unprecedentedly.

To Despardo, whilst in principal I agree with you that Pakistan should have restricted imports of non-essential items, specially in past few months, as it has increased CAD considerably and has put pressure on BOP, and brining in Tarin as FM was a mistake, as gains for past 3 years is fast eroding, though now steps are being taken to avert CAD and BOP crisis. However, for reasons best known to you, you seems to through in figure out of nowhere and which are factually incorrect (likes this 80% wheat or even 80% food import and even before SBP put out actual figures you quoted reserves has decreased by 400m, when in fact they went up by $2.5bn), that only damages your credibility, even when you have a valid point to prove. Probably time to take a little break..........
Sir you can check that from July 2020 to March 2021 things was cheaper than 2017-2018. You can check sir i am here and i am glad to proven wrong.
 

RajaRawal111

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
بھڑوا لیگ اپنے لفافی اخباروں میں جھوٹی خبریں چھپواتے ہیں،، اور پھر مُودے کنجر کے شاگرد درباری،، اور تم جیسے کیڑے مکوڑےپٹواری حرامزادے، اُسکو مدھانی میں ڈال کر کانجی، یا لسّی کی شکل دیکر بیچتے کی کوشش کرتے ہیں

ایک باپ 'اپنے پٹواری پُتر کو ڈانٹ پلاتے ہوئے ۔ ۔ ۔
بہن چود ،،،،، دیانت داری کر،،حلال دی کھا

یار تجھے پہلے بھی بتایا تھا - یہ گالیاں بکنے والے تم عمرانویوں کے باپ ہی ہو سکتے ہیں
پٹواری غریبوں کے باپ بہت تنگ ہو جایں تو بیچاروں کو جھولی اٹھا کر بددعایں ہی دینی آتی ہیں


https://twitter.com/x/status/1219119911076798464
 

Okara

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
Sir you can check that from July 2020 to March 2021 things was cheaper than 2017-2018. You can check sir i am here and i am glad to proven wrong.
Please check this. U can select 5 years trend.
 

Malik_007

Senator (1k+ posts)
And how u came to know this 80% figure?
Bilkoool wesay he jesay 2 din pehlay yeh Kanjar PKR 97 wali dawai ko photoshop py PKR 426 bana k sale kr raha tha or keh raha tha k Imran Khan nay dekho kia zulm kia ha !!! umeed ha wo thread aapki nazron sy guzra hoga? warna main link paish krta hon aap ja k daikh ly or phir ja k us dawai ki price online check krlain 5-6 sites py...
 

Doom1111

Minister (2k+ posts)
Raja Sahib
Nawaz's father was a rich person while Shahbaz's father was a poor man. Who is Patwari from both brothers?
Sir live in Lahore. People are dying for Shahbaz Shrif Autocratic governance.

People are fed up of PTI in Punjab

When Shahbaz was Cm every single day the district officer used to go check the prices of daily item early in the morning and made sure that the prices is not increased and according to the government rate ,however, Buzdar came i have not seen 1 single time a district officer working.