PML(N) and PTI Mid-Term Report Cards

arafay

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
oK here is an objective look at how pti and pml (n) is faring in their respective govts in province and center with respect to the benchmarks/promises they made in the run up to the 2013 elections. I have pretty good memory and have been following current affairs and based on my knowledge i came up with the following mid term rerpot card for each party.

My scoring criteria is simple

promise fulfilled = 1 mark
promise partially fulfilled = 0.5 mark
promise was not fulfilled = 0 mark
u-turn on promise = -1 mark


Report Card of PML N as of 18 October 2015

1) Bullet train from karachi to lahore = 0
2) End load shedding in 6 months/ 1 year / 3 year = 0
3) Drag zardari on streets of Lahore, Karachi and Larkana = -1 (nawaz sharif actively helped ppp and zardari)
4) Kashkol torna = -1 (nawaz sharif has taken the most expensive loans in the world and went to IMF)
5) youth loan scheme = 1
6) reduce taxes to 10% = -1 (nawaz sharif increased tax burden through record indirect taxes on utilities/fuel)
7) increase tax net/base = 0
8) good governance = 0

so mid-term score for pmln is -2/8 = -25%

Report Card of PTI as of 18 October 2015

1) Change police culture = 1
2) Change patwari culture = 1
3) Improve healthcare = 0
4) Improve education = 0.5 (only primary education has improved)
5) Setup local govts in 3 months = 0.5 (local govts were eventually setup but after 3 months had passed)
6) Make govt accountable = 1 (RTI, right to services, whistle blower law)
7) Catch & eliminate corruption = 0.5 (some corrupt guys were caught but easy load crooks are still free)
8) Open governor house/cm house for public = 0.5 (only rest houses are opened)

so mid-term score for pti is 5/8 = 62.5%

So even though it was first govt ever for PTI (and that too with coalition partners and strong fight with federal govt), they are far ahead of PMLN in delivery at the half-way stage. Even i was surprised by the high score of pti because we are only half way through and for eg, pti can improve on promises (3), (4) and (7) to being their total score after 5 years to 7/8 = 87.5% - quite amazing!

side note: It is unbelievable how poor PTI media management really is. They cant even go through past promises and create a white paper and distribute it in media. A truly shameful effort by media team mostly managed by old/nazarayti members.

All credit goes to IK and Khattak for this good performance and shame on mariam for this worst performance in pakistan's history.

P.S. If anyone has info of other promises then let me know and i will update the report.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

GreenMaple

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
Excellent effort. Thanks for sharing. Now that the major distractions are behind him, IK will be putting a lot more effort to fulfill the remaining promised agenda.
 

farooq22

Minister (2k+ posts)
Theory or practical mein fark huta h Pappu Burger

Theory damag mein huti h ya lafafa media/social media ki zaban par. Practical zameen par nazar ata h.

Chor report card ko, koi aik cheez dekha KPK mein jo Pasha Party ny ki or zameen par dekhti hu
 

mh.saghir

Minister (2k+ posts)
Theory or practical mein fark huta h Pappu Burger

Theory damag mein huti h ya lafafa media/social media ki zaban par. Practical zameen par nazar ata h.

Chor report card ko, koi aik cheez dekha KPK mein jo Pasha Party ny ki or zameen par dekhti hu

bhai na unho ny metro aur roads bnany ka kaha tha aur na kheti ugany ka; PTI ka wada idary bnany ka tha.

Police thek honay sy aman-o-aman ki sorat-e-haal behtr ho gi, logon ko behtr aur pur sukon mahool mily ga jis may woh behtr andaz sy apny mamulaat sir anjam dy sken.

Ehtisab ka idara behtr honay sy logon ki looti hoi dolat wapis aaey gi jo un py kharach ki ja sky gi, mazeed.

Local bodies logon ko nichli satah tk un ki zroryat fraham kr sken gi.

MNA aur MPA ka kam nhi hy road aur sarken bnana, in kamon k liye loca numaindy aur idary hoty hain. 2.5 saal ho gaey, umeed hy ab idaron ki tassih ka marhala mukammal honay k baad yeh idary apni progress bhi dikhana start kr den gy. Insha Allah! Aur phr aap apni aankh sy dekh bhi lena k kuch nazr aany wala kaam hoa hy ya nhi.
 

mubashirrao

MPA (400+ posts)
Theory or practical mein fark huta h Pappu Burger

Theory damag mein huti h ya lafafa media/social media ki zaban par. Practical zameen par nazar ata h.

Chor report card ko, koi aik cheez dekha KPK mein jo Pasha Party ny ki or zameen par dekhti hu

آنکھیں ہیں یا کسی بلغاری باندر کی گولیاں؟
بی سی انا ویں ؟ آنکھاں کھول تے گراونڈ تے ویکھ ذرا کی فرق آ
چولاں مارن تو باز نی آنا جے تساں
 

Talwar Gujjar

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Score k pata nahein lekin PTI k jo jootay paray hein, un mein se outstanding kuch u hein:

D-chowk mein karaey k dharna 75 littar
Haripur mein Reham Khan aur Jhoot Khan k dhullaee: 12 littar
NA122 mein taza taza, garam garam pitaee: 13 littar

PTI puray 100 littar aur ab ganday khanay k baari aanay wali ha.
 
Last edited:

rizhussain44

MPA (400+ posts)
Just one thing bro, i think governor house federal government kay control mai hotay hain, provvincal government kay control mai nahi
 

Theekra

Senator (1k+ posts)
PMLN Promises:

1: Will reduce terrorism, negotiate with Taliban and do operation where needed: 1
2: Improve economy, reduce inflation, privatize SOEs: 1
3: Peace in Karachi and Balochistan: 1
4: Reduce debts: -1
6: End/Reduce load-shedding in 2-3 years: 0.5
7: Infrastructure in smaller cities/Bullet trains etc: 0.5

Total: 3/7

PTI promises:

1: Conduct local body elections: 1
2: Open governor houses etc: 1
3: End terrorism in 90 days: 0.5 (better than ANP govt but still too little)
4: End corruption in 30 days: -1 (QWP is in govt. now :) )
5: Will never lie to people: -1 (35 punctures was a 'political' statement:IK)
6: Will build 250 dams: 0
7: Will conduct elections in Police: -1

Total: -0.5/7
 
Last edited:

ThirdUmpireFinger

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Pootians are still living in dharna world. Wake up bcoz bonga khan not only wasted his time but whole nations time in fazooliat. For dharna drama i gave him -1000.
 

fawad ali

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
PMLN Promises:

1: Will reduce terrorism, negotiate with Taliban and do operation where needed: 1
2: Improve economy, reduce inflation, privatize SOEs: 1
3: Peace in Karachi and Balochistan: 1
4: Reduce debts: -1
6: End/Reduce load-shedding in 2-3 years: 0.5
7: Infrastructure in smaller cities/Bullet trains etc: 0.5

Total: 3/7

PTI promises:

1: Conduct local body elections: 1
2: Open governor houses etc: 1
3: End terrorism in 90 days: 0.5 (better than ANP govt but still too little)
4: End corruption in 30 days: -1 (QWP is in govt. now :) )
5: Will never lie to people: -1 (35 punctures was a 'political' statement:IK)
6: Will build 250 dams: 0
7: Will conduct elections in Police: -1

Total: -0.5/7
Wrong evaluation. Conducting elections in police was not the target, but only a way to reach the target. The target was to make it efficient and non political. This is what they have done. So for me, Police efficiency and non political interferrence = 2...... End of corruption again =2 because PTI minister is in jail, whereas corrupt ministers of QWP are kicked out as well. Does not mean whole of QWP were corrupt. against 2 marks, Agree with other 5 scorings
 

fawad ali

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
PMLn score

1: Producing electricity = 0.1
2: Police reforms = 0
3: Accountability = 0
4: Transparency = 0.1
5: infra structure development = 1
6: making institutions = 0
7: Good governance = 0.2

Total score = 2.4 / 7

PTI score:

1: Producing electricity = 0.2
2: Police reforms = 1
3: Accountability = 1
4: Transparency = 1
5: infra structure development = 0.1
6: making institutions = 1
7: Good governance = 0.2

Total score = 4.5 / 7

So PTI scores double than PMLn , despite the fact that it is their first time in government.
 

Abdul jabbar

Minister (2k+ posts)
​تم ایک شخص کو ہمیشہ کے لئے دھوکے میں رکھ سکتے ہو،
تم بہت سے آدمیوں کو کچھ عرصہ تک دھوکے میں رکھ سکتے ہو،
لیکن تمام آدمیوں کو ہمیشہ کے لئے دھوکے میں نہیں رکھ سکتے۔
ابراہام لنکن
 

just_saying

MPA (400+ posts)
PMLn score

1: Producing electricity = 0.1
2: Police reforms = 0
3: Accountability = 0
4: Transparency = 0.1
5: infra structure development = 1
6: making institutions = 0
7: Good governance = 0.2

Total score = 2.4 / 7

PTI score:

1: Producing electricity = 0.2
2: Police reforms = 1
3: Accountability = 1
4: Transparency = 1
5: infra structure development = 0.1
6: making institutions = 1
7: Good governance = 0.2

Total score = 4.5 / 7

So PTI scores double than PMLn , despite the fact that it is their first time in government.


Itni doodh ki nehren bahane k bawajood PTI har election may zaleel aur ruswa q ho rai hai