Should alcohol be legalised?

[JunaidMarwat]

Kindly give reasons for why it should be legalised and why it should not be legalised.

1. Legalising alcohol will bring tons on investment into breweries creating thousands of jobs and thus helping us in collect more tax. If cigarettes is such a big industry I think alcohol would be bigger. ZAB banned alcohol to please the mullah vote bank. Hypocrisy.
2. Pakistan is missing on a whole industry called night life, that would generate so many jobs in the F&B sector and also add life to our dead entertainment sector.
3. It will give boost to tourism and also people in the villages who drink substandard kachi sharab would not lose their lives.
4. Export opportunities.
5. Yesterday, it was shameful how Alizeh Shah was being slut shammed for wearing a tank top by Pakistani men on twitter when there were more important thing trending such as Palestine etc. These self righteous males makes us one of the top porn consuming countries. Another feather in their cap is to make 50 shades of grey trend in the month of Ramzan. Also, this mullah mentality is lethal. We will never go forward as long as this exists.
6. Will eliminate the bootlegger mafia that is currently existent in every city. Murree Brewery would not be growing yoy if we did not enjoy our occasional pint.
7. Efes Turkey gives employment to I guess 20000 people, can't we be a normal moderate country like them. Live and let live.

Cons

1. I see a lot of accidents happening, would be difficult to control driving under influence.
2. Pakistanis are extremist by nature I see a lot of people becoming alcoholic.
3. Fights taking place under the influence in clubs or pubs.

 

[Baadshaah]

پاکستانی قوم کی اکثریت منافق ہے، اندرخانے یہ شراب بھی پیتے ہیں، گرل فرینڈ، بوائے فرینڈ کلچر بھی ہے، مگر اس کو قبول نہیں کرنا۔ شراب کو پاکستان میں لیگلائز کرنا چاہئے، پاکستان میں ٹوئرزم کو فروغ دینے کیلئے کلب اور بار بھی بنانے چاہئیں۔ شراب کو لیگائز کرنے سے پاکستان کا نقصان نہیں فائدہ ہی فائدہ ہوگا۔ قوم کی بہت سی فرسٹریشن بھی بذریعہ شراب نکل جایا کرے گی۔ باقی جس کو نہیں پینی وہ نہ پیے کوئی زبردستی تو نہیں، ہاں مگر جو پینا چاہتے ہیں ان کو زبردستی کیوں روکا جائے۔۔؟ ​

 

[A.jokhio]

Kindly give reasons for why it should be legalised and why it should not be legalised.

1. Legalising alcohol will bring tons on investment into breweries creating thousands of jobs and thus helping us in collect more tax. If cigarettes is such a big industry I think alcohol would be bigger. ZAB banned alcohol to please the mullah vote bank. Hypocrisy.
2. Pakistan is missing on a whole industry called night life, that would generate so many jobs in the F&B sector and also add life to our dead entertainment sector.
3. It will give boost to tourism and also people in the villages who drink substandard kachi sharab would not lose their lives.
4. Export opportunities.
5. Yesterday, it was shameful how Alizeh Shah was being slut shammed for wearing a tank top by Pakistani men on twitter when there were more important thing trending such as Palestine etc. These self righteous males makes us one of the top porn consuming countries. Another feather in their cap is to make 50 shades of grey trend in the month of Ramzan. Also, this mullah mentality is lethal. We will never go forward as long as this exists.
6. Will eliminate the bootlegger mafia that is currently existent in every city. Murree Brewery would not be growing yoy if we did not enjoy our occasional pint.
7. Efes Turkey gives employment to I guess 20000 people, can't we be a normal moderate country like them. Live and let live.

Cons

1. I see a lot of accidents happening, would be difficult to control driving under influence.
2. Pakistanis are extremist by nature I see a lot of people becoming alcoholic.
3. Fights taking place under the influence in clubs or pubs.

What kind of question is this...how could any one even ask about the legitimacy of thing which is prohibited in Quran and Sunnah????

 

[Dr Adam]

What kind of question is this...how could any one even ask about the legitimacy of thing which is prohibited in Quran and Sunnah????

Yes and End of the Story.

 

[kakamuna420]

non-alcoholic beers are very healthy and profitable businesses. We should invite foreign companies to make such beverages in Pakistan.

 

[Haha]

اسکے بعد ایک سوال کیا جائے گا
کہ کیا زنا کو لیگلائز کر دیا جائے
تاکہ ریپ رک جائیں ?

 

[JunaidMarwat]

What kind of question is this...how could any one even ask about the legitimacy of thing which is prohibited in Quran and Sunnah????

The Quran says its prohibited but its not forbidden, it was actually banned in Hazrat Umar time. Before him Khamar was widely consumed in the region. Also, if you do not want to drink don't. Why are you enforcing it on others? If Allah wanted everyone would have been an angel but he gave us free will.

 

[JunaidMarwat]

اسکے بعد ایک سوال کیا جائے گا
کہ کیا زنا کو لیگلائز کر دیا جائے
تاکہ ریپ رک جائیں ?

No, you are not causing anyone harm by drinking. Otherwise ban cigarettes as well.

 

[JunaidMarwat]

non-alcoholic beers are very healthy and profitable businesses. We should invite foreign companies to make such beverages in Pakistan.

I think Amstel already introduced a few non alcoholic beverages, haven't tried them yet

 

[JunaidMarwat]

پاکستانی قوم کی اکثریت منافق ہے، اندرخانے یہ شراب بھی پیتے ہیں، گرل فرینڈ، بوائے فرینڈ کلچر بھی ہے، مگر اس کو قبول نہیں کرنا۔ شراب کو پاکستان میں لیگلائز کرنا چاہئے، پاکستان میں ٹوئرزم کو فروغ دینے کیلئے کلب اور بار بھی بنانے چاہئیں۔ شراب کو لیگائز کرنے سے پاکستان کا نقصان نہیں فائدہ ہی فائدہ ہوگا۔ قوم کی بہت سی فرسٹریشن بھی بذریعہ شراب نکل جایا کرے گی۔ باقی جس کو نہیں پینی وہ نہ پیے کوئی زبردستی تو نہیں، ہاں مگر جو پینا چاہتے ہیں ان کو زبردستی کیوں روکا جائے۔۔؟ ​

Wow man you spoke in Urdu but clearly put the ball out of the park for a six. Bilkul sahi kaha aap ne

 

[MMushtaq]

Kindly give reasons for why it should be legalised and why it should not be legalised.

1. Legalising alcohol will bring tons on investment into breweries creating thousands of jobs and thus helping us in collect more tax. If cigarettes is such a big industry I think alcohol would be bigger. ZAB banned alcohol to please the mullah vote bank. Hypocrisy.
2. Pakistan is missing on a whole industry called night life, that would generate so many jobs in the F&B sector and also add life to our dead entertainment sector.
3. It will give boost to tourism and also people in the villages who drink substandard kachi sharab would not lose their lives.
4. Export opportunities.
5. Yesterday, it was shameful how Alizeh Shah was being slut shammed for wearing a tank top by Pakistani men on twitter when there were more important thing trending such as Palestine etc. These self righteous males makes us one of the top porn consuming countries. Another feather in their cap is to make 50 shades of grey trend in the month of Ramzan. Also, this mullah mentality is lethal. We will never go forward as long as this exists.
6. Will eliminate the bootlegger mafia that is currently existent in every city. Murree Brewery would not be growing yoy if we did not enjoy our occasional pint.
7. Efes Turkey gives employment to I guess 20000 people, can't we be a normal moderate country like them. Live and let live.

Cons

1. I see a lot of accidents happening, would be difficult to control driving under influence.
2. Pakistanis are extremist by nature I see a lot of people becoming alcoholic.
3. Fights taking place under the influence in clubs or pubs.

YES.

 

[Immu123]

For me there is only 1 answer what Quran says.
It’s not allowed in any circumstances.

 

[Haha]

No, you are not causing anyone harm by drinking. Otherwise ban cigarettes as well.

سر ڈرنک ڈرائیونگ ول اور می کاز حارم ٹو مینی پیپل
Sir
Drink driving may cause harm to many other people as well

 

[JunaidMarwat]

Our higher officers in the army drink , our politician drink, bureaucrats love their drinks. Till when are we gonna keep our masses living in ignorance, we need to change with changing times. Otherwise we will fall behind everyone.

 

[JunaidMarwat]

For me there is only 1 answer what Quran says.
It’s not allowed in any circumstances.

It says its prohibited but not forbidden. And the reason why its prohibited is because in it lies a way towards sin, ppl in those days would drink and commit heinous acts like murders, rape and burglary. You do not need to get out of control.

 

[JunaidMarwat]

سر ڈرنک ڈرائیونگ ول اور می کاز حارم ٹو مینی پیپل
Sir
Drink driving may cause harm to many other people as well

Thats my fear but a lot of teenagers already do that. Since they can't enjoy a few beers at a restaurant or a pub they drink in their cars while driving. Sad but true

 

[Okara]

پاکستانی قوم کی اکثریت منافق ہے، اندرخانے یہ شراب بھی پیتے ہیں، گرل فرینڈ، بوائے فرینڈ کلچر بھی ہے، مگر اس کو قبول نہیں کرنا۔ شراب کو پاکستان میں لیگلائز کرنا چاہئے، پاکستان میں ٹوئرزم کو فروغ دینے کیلئے کلب اور بار بھی بنانے چاہئیں۔ شراب کو لیگائز کرنے سے پاکستان کا نقصان نہیں فائدہ ہی فائدہ ہوگا۔ قوم کی بہت سی فرسٹریشن بھی بذریعہ شراب نکل جایا کرے گی۔ باقی جس کو نہیں پینی وہ نہ پیے کوئی زبردستی تو نہیں، ہاں مگر جو پینا چاہتے ہیں ان کو زبردستی کیوں روکا جائے۔۔؟ ​

But on packing it should be label as honey or government can approach Sharjeel Memon to suggest a better name? BTW there are lot of Molvi in Pakistan who can happily give Fatwa to legalize it.
Hazrat Usman Ghani RA wasted all the Alcohol which he was bringing to Madina from a long distance and not realizing it can generate lot of economic in Madina?
BTW do you think we should legalize only Alcohol or other drugs as well to attract tourists from all over the world?

 

[Haha]

It says its prohibited but not forbidden. And the reason why its prohibited is because in it lies a way towards sin, ppl in those days would drink and commit heinous acts like murders, rape and burglary. You do not need to get out of control.

یار مروت بھائی آپ کے دلائل مروت والے کمُ اور قاضی عیسئی والے زیادہ لگتے ہیں۔ آپ کہں جج تو نہیں بھئی اگر آپ بہت سے اور لوگوں کی طرح قاضی عئیسی کے فیصلے کے بعد جج کہنے کو گالی سمجھتے ہیں تو معزرت

 

[JunaidMarwat]

YES.

Reason brother

 

[kakamuna420]

No, you are not causing anyone harm by drinking. Otherwise ban cigarettes as well.

you might be drunk when writing this. LOL!!