Judicary-Media Mafia
MPA (400+ posts)
Last edited:
Why Muslims Have Mosque In Non Muslim Countries,Other Religions Can’t In PK
- Thread starter Judicary-Media Mafia
- Start date
Hussain1967
Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Kia dangron wali post hain. There are churches and temples in Pakistan. No one is closing them. It is the duty of Muslim State to protect the lives, wealth, and worship-place of non-Muslims in response to the taxes ( Jizia) paid by non-Muslims to Muslim State.
You are trying to mix two different things. One is the permission to have worship place for non-Muslims. Other is the Muslim-State using its resources ( including the taxes paid by non-Muslims) in building the workshop place for non-Muslims. First one is permissible in Islam while second is not.
You are trying to mix two different things. One is the permission to have worship place for non-Muslims. Other is the Muslim-State using its resources ( including the taxes paid by non-Muslims) in building the workshop place for non-Muslims. First one is permissible in Islam while second is not.
Judicary-Media Mafia
MPA (400+ posts)
Kia Haraam Kor molvie hain tu; Why you not letting hindus make temple in islamabad you donkey eating patwari or tu bhut bara juta hain its not government funded. you are a liar
Don't twist the matter my dear,we are not against the construction of temple in Islamabad we are against the decsion of government funding for this temple, and for your kind information all the Mosques build in non-muslim countries are build by the community themswelves and they are run by the communities own contributions.,even the land/properties are bought by the communities themselves.
Imran Siddiqi
Minister (2k+ posts)
This is PAKISTAN
Imran Siddiqi
Minister (2k+ posts)
For 100s of years there was not a single mosque in Spain...
Wadaich
Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
And earlier on they demolished hundreds.
Its true in UK all churches are also looked after and paid for by christian communities taxpayers money is not used by govt to fund any religion
Whereas in Pakistan some mosques are build and funded by tax payers such as all mosques in Islamabad were build by CDA and in KPK Imams get monthly salaries from KPK govt.
There are few question here 10% of population of Pakistan is non Muslim but they pay taxes just as other citizens.
Is it right to use their tax to fund Islamic religion only
Why shouldnt they get 10% of what govt spends on funding Muslims religios activity.
We need to seprate Zukat donations and tax money separately and then apply rules
Another point to ponder about is that a State is man made entity it cant speak for it self its parliament has decided that it will run on Islamic laws. But in many cases it does not such as interest, criminal laws, premium bonds lottery not to mention the social ills such as corruption etc.
JusticeLover
Minister (2k+ posts)
State resources cannot be used for building temples , repairing historical cultural building which includes temples and religious place is permitted to preserve historical importance buildings.
Imranpak
Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Firstly understand that the west is secular where as Pakistan claims to be Islamic. If the west followed Christian law most likely they too would not allow so many Masjid's to be constructed. The historical Sikh temples are still standing in Pak then we have also opened the Nankana up for the Sikh community. My beef with constructing a temple in Islamabad is firstly the demolition of Masjid's in India then there are hardly any Hindu's in Islamabad.
Last edited:
Raiwind-Destroyer
Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
i agree that mullahs of pakistan should take more participation in politics and stand against corruption because its against islam but that is not the justification to build hindu temples
we should focus on what we can do to fix corruption in the light of islam
we should focus on what we can do to fix corruption in the light of islam
Judicary-Media Mafia
MPA (400+ posts)
bu
But government is not funding the temple who told you?
Judicary-Media Mafia
MPA (400+ posts)
state is not funding Pmln time the plan started
i read in the media
Judicary-Media Mafia
MPA (400+ posts)
but its lies its propaganda like lot of other fake news. Why would government want to fund temple there so many other important things waiting for funds. Hindus only want permission to build it
Pakistani1947
Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Pakistan was made in the name of Islam. There are more than 98% Muslims in this country. Due to its religious background we can not compare Pakistan with other countries.
In my opinion non-Muslims should be allowed to build their places of worship at their own expenses and there should be some kind of mechanism that they should take NOC before starting any such project. Government should make sure that there is reasonable concentration of followers of that particular religion to justify its construction. Other factor could be considered such as sensitivity of locals towards other religion to minimize clashes, also security concerns in sensitive areas like Islamabad red zone, closeness with military installations, and airport etc.,
In my opinion non-Muslims should be allowed to build their places of worship at their own expenses and there should be some kind of mechanism that they should take NOC before starting any such project. Government should make sure that there is reasonable concentration of followers of that particular religion to justify its construction. Other factor could be considered such as sensitivity of locals towards other religion to minimize clashes, also security concerns in sensitive areas like Islamabad red zone, closeness with military installations, and airport etc.,
Last edited:
