حضرت صاحب۔۔ پہلے یہ تو فرمائیے کہ یہ جو اسلام آپ کے بقول خدا نے نازل فرمایا اس کی ہر کوئی الگ الگ انٹرپریٹیشن کیوں کرتا پھرتا ہے؟ آپ اپنا الگ اسلام لئے پھررہے ہیں، فورم پر دو حضرات ہیں وہ اپنا الگ اسلام لئے پھررہے ہیں، دیگر اکثریتی مسلمان ہیں، وہ اپنا الگ اسلام لئے پھررہے ہیں۔ اگر آپ لوگوں کے بقول یہ پیغام کسی اصلی خدا کی طرف سے آیا ہے تو کیا وہ خدا اتنی ہی اہلیت نہیں رکھتا کہ اپنے بندوں کو اپنا پیغام سمجھا سکے؟ جس مسلمان سے بات کرو وہ کہتا ہے اسلام یہ نہیں، اسلام وہ ہے۔ اسلام نہ ہوگیا چوں چوں کا مربہ ہوگیا۔۔
کوئی بھی سائنسدان، معیشت دان، تاریخ دان، کیمیا دان جب کوئی کتاب لکھتا ہے تو اس کو پڑھنے والے سب لوگ اس کو سمجھتے ہیں اور کتاب سے وہی کچھ اخذ کرتے ہیں جو لکھنے والا اپنے قارئین تک پہنچانا چاہتا ہے۔ آج تک کارل مارکس کی داس کیپٹل کو سمجھنے میں کسی کو دشواری پیش نہیں آئی، ایڈم سمتھ کی" ویلتھ آف نیشنز" سے لوگوں نے مختلف مطالب نہیں نکالے، ایمانوئل کانٹ کی "کریٹیک آف پیور ریزن"پر پڑھنے والوں کے اختلافات نہیں ہوئے، چارلس ڈارون کی "آن دی اوریجن آف سپیشیز" پر چار سو تفاسیر لکھنے کی ضرورت پیش نہیں آئی، غرضیکہ جب بھی قابل انسانوں نے کچھ لکھا، اس کو بڑی مہارت کے ساتھ اپنے قارئین تک پہنچایا اور سب نے وہی سمجھا جو لکھنے والے نے لکھا۔مگر آپ کی مذہبی کتابیں لکھنے والے تو اتنی اہلیت بھی نہیں رکھتے تھے کہ لوگوں کو اپنا پیغام بلا اختلاف اور بلا ابہام سمجھا سکیں۔
آپ مسلمان حضرات کیلئے میرا ایک ہی مشورہ ہے کہ جس کتاب کو آپ خدا کی طرف سے بھیجی ہوئی کتاب مانتے ہیں، پہلے سارے مسلمان بیٹھ کر اس کتاب کا ایک متفقہ ترجمہ کرلیں، پہلے خود اس کو سمجھ لیں کہ اس میں لکھا کیا ہے، پھر اس کتاب کے متفقہ ترجمہ پر آپ سے بات کرلیں گے۔ فی الحال آپ میرا اور اپنا وقت ضائع کررہے ہیں، کیونکہ آپ اسلام کی ایک نئی ٹانگ اٹھائے پھررہے ہیں اور اکثریتی مسلمانوں کے پاس اسلام کی جو ٹانگ ہے وہ الگ ہے۔ دونوں ٹانگوں کو جوڑ کر ایک وجود بنالیں پھر آپ سے بات ہوجائے گی۔۔
dear m shameer sb, you are very, very confused about each and everything. You are telling me so and so has written such and such book and everyone understands it. This is a clear cut false statement of yours. It is because that is not the way God has created mankind. People come in all ages and because their ages and understandings vary so they all cannot have exactly the same understanding about anything at all. This is impossible to say the least.
I never said each and every person understands the quran perfectly just because the quran is a book from God. This is why you should go through my posts because in there I explain all these like points as to why their are differences about understanding of the quran between people. There is a big difference between understanding of children and grown ups about things. Also there is a big difference between understanding of educated, trained and skilled people about things and those who are not educated and trained and they lack skills.
Not only that but understanding of things can only be correct of those people who can explain things according to indisputable facts. This is why all those people who have been trying to explain things randomly their understanding and explanation has led human world to what it is now right before our very eyes ie this is all result or outcome of that.
This is why I said I have explained things as I understand them according to which human world should be set up and run or managed and then see the result for doing that. Also see my explanation for yourself and see if there is anything wrong with it and see if you can do better by coming up with a better explanation for humanity to live by. So there is no point in keep jumping from one thing to another.
I have been asking all people I came across to explain the way to make purpose based proper sense of the quranic text but so far none has come up with one based upon indisputable facts. The same challenge stands for you as well. I have clearly explained how I have arrived at my interpretation and explanation of the quranic text. See if you can find any faults in it. If my way of explaining the quranic text is right then it matters not who else interprets and explains the quranic text because that explanation or interpretation will also be either right or wrong because facts always remain facts.
So it matters not how many interpretations or explanations of the quranic text are there in the human world but what matters is if any of them is right due to being based upon facts. if other interpretations and explanations of the quranic text are wrong then they do not matter and if they are right then they will be similar to mine so you cannot use the difference between interpretations and explanation of the quran to discredit the quran.
Moreover when one accepts possibility of existence of God then one cannot say God cannot communicate with his creation and particularly with human beings. All we human beings can do is examine the alleged communication of God with human beings and see if it makes purpose based proper sense or not. If it does then it is truly from God and if it does not then it is not from God. This is how simple the process is to test it. Moreover there are no many books claiming to be revelations from God rather it is only and only the quran which makes such a claim in our human world. This makes things yet easier for us human beings.
So even if I am alone in telling what is true, it is still true and falsehood is false even if the whole human world backs it up. Only and only the quran gives us universal moral values to live by if we try and understand it in light of real world realities as I have explained in my posts on this forum. So your claims against the quran are not valid at all and that is because you are basing your evidences on information which itself is doubtful till it is purposefully properly sorted out.
The quran is all about universal overall ideology for mankind for their bringing about a purpose based proper human community according to it.
As I see things you are not trying to understand things but only and only trying to argue for sake of argument otherwise you would have read my posts to see how I explain things and whether they are right or wrong and if wrong why?
regards and all the best.
