Fittay Munh.
Asma Jahangir urges civilians to challenge army
Reuters Yesterday
The government needs to make legislation on intelligence agencies. They need to debate the defence budget. They don't need to cut it but at least they need to debate it, said Jahangir.File photo
The armys image has been dented by a number of setbacks starting with the killing of Osama bin Laden last month by US special forces on Pakistani soil. Traditionally seen as untouchable, Pakistans generals now face strong public criticism.
Asma Jahangir, a leading human rights campaigner and head of the Supreme Court Bar Association, said the mood in the country provided an opportunity to start correcting a lopsided balance of power between the army and the civilian government.
I am hopeful that public opinion will finally embolden civil society, including politicians. But its not going to happen tomorrow morning, she told Reuters in a telephone interview.
Its going to be a perpetual struggle. They are not just going to hand over and say thank you very much we are now under civilian control. But at least they know thats what people want now.
The military has ruled nuclear-armed Pakistan for more than half of its history. Generals set security and foreign policy, even when civilian governments are in power, as is the case now.
The 600,000-strong army also runs a vast business empire that includes oil and gas interests, cereals and real estate.
Our parliament has to strengthen itself for anyone to change because nobody hands over power just voluntarily, said Jahangir.
The parliament will have to be more forceful and also begin to realise that they (the army) cant hold the economy of this country hostage, foreign policy hostage.
Pakistans civilian leaders dont seem willing to stand up to the military in a country prone to army coups. Generals often orchestrate Pakistani politics from behind the scenes.
They have selfishly overlooked the interests of the people of Pakistan. We think that its time to change, said Jahangir.
The army says it does not interfere in politics and reiterated its commitment to democracy in a statement issued this month.
Jahangir said she is hopeful of change because the military has been on the defensive. The United States kept Pakistan in the dark over the raid that killed bin Laden, humiliating the army and then piling pressure on it to crack down harder on militancy.
About 25 percent of government expenditure flows to the defence budget, according to some estimates, in a country with widespread poverty and social inequalities.
The government needs to make legislation on intelligence agencies. They need to debate the defence budget. They dont need to cut it but at least they need to debate it, said Jahangir.
There are parliamentary committees that are oversight structures for them. And there needs to be more parliamentary committees which are more effective.
To make matters worse for the military, suspicion fell on its Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) spy agency after a prominent Pakistani journalist was tortured to death and dumped in a canal. The ISI said it played no role in his death.
Then the killing of an apparently unarmed man by paramilitary forces which was caught on videotape further eroded what little public confidence remains in Pakistans security forces.
Jahangir said politicians and Pakistanis should move swiftly, but cautiously, to try and strengthen civilian institutions while the military seems vulnerable.
Momentarily they are a bit worried. They are vulnerable to the extent that people are besieging them to change. It is critical, she said.
They have a way of overcoming it too. They know that this is momentary. They will soon start getting their civilian counterparts to change public opinion to confuse the issue, to demonise people. We have seen it happen before.
http://www.dawn.com/2011/06/21/asma-jahangir-urges-civilians-to-challenge-army.html
Asma Jahangir urges civilians to challenge army
Reuters Yesterday
ISLAMABAD: Pakistans civilian leaders should capitalise on public anger with the military and try to ease its grip on power, a leading human rights activist and lawyer said on Tuesday.The armys image has been dented by a number of setbacks starting with the killing of Osama bin Laden last month by US special forces on Pakistani soil. Traditionally seen as untouchable, Pakistans generals now face strong public criticism.
Asma Jahangir, a leading human rights campaigner and head of the Supreme Court Bar Association, said the mood in the country provided an opportunity to start correcting a lopsided balance of power between the army and the civilian government.
I am hopeful that public opinion will finally embolden civil society, including politicians. But its not going to happen tomorrow morning, she told Reuters in a telephone interview.
Its going to be a perpetual struggle. They are not just going to hand over and say thank you very much we are now under civilian control. But at least they know thats what people want now.
The military has ruled nuclear-armed Pakistan for more than half of its history. Generals set security and foreign policy, even when civilian governments are in power, as is the case now.
The 600,000-strong army also runs a vast business empire that includes oil and gas interests, cereals and real estate.
Our parliament has to strengthen itself for anyone to change because nobody hands over power just voluntarily, said Jahangir.
The parliament will have to be more forceful and also begin to realise that they (the army) cant hold the economy of this country hostage, foreign policy hostage.
Pakistans civilian leaders dont seem willing to stand up to the military in a country prone to army coups. Generals often orchestrate Pakistani politics from behind the scenes.
They have selfishly overlooked the interests of the people of Pakistan. We think that its time to change, said Jahangir.
The army says it does not interfere in politics and reiterated its commitment to democracy in a statement issued this month.
Jahangir said she is hopeful of change because the military has been on the defensive. The United States kept Pakistan in the dark over the raid that killed bin Laden, humiliating the army and then piling pressure on it to crack down harder on militancy.
About 25 percent of government expenditure flows to the defence budget, according to some estimates, in a country with widespread poverty and social inequalities.
The government needs to make legislation on intelligence agencies. They need to debate the defence budget. They dont need to cut it but at least they need to debate it, said Jahangir.
There are parliamentary committees that are oversight structures for them. And there needs to be more parliamentary committees which are more effective.
To make matters worse for the military, suspicion fell on its Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) spy agency after a prominent Pakistani journalist was tortured to death and dumped in a canal. The ISI said it played no role in his death.
Then the killing of an apparently unarmed man by paramilitary forces which was caught on videotape further eroded what little public confidence remains in Pakistans security forces.
Jahangir said politicians and Pakistanis should move swiftly, but cautiously, to try and strengthen civilian institutions while the military seems vulnerable.
Momentarily they are a bit worried. They are vulnerable to the extent that people are besieging them to change. It is critical, she said.
They have a way of overcoming it too. They know that this is momentary. They will soon start getting their civilian counterparts to change public opinion to confuse the issue, to demonise people. We have seen it happen before.
http://www.dawn.com/2011/06/21/asma-jahangir-urges-civilians-to-challenge-army.html
