Islam doesn't allow to collect taxes?

[atensari]

Re: Islam doesn't allow to collect taxes

I do not exactly know how Zakat has been referred as, in Quran, apart from being called Zakat. So I cannot answer your exact question. The term "tax" did not exist then so I am certain it is not that.

But if I were to interpret the concept of Zakat, it is nothing but "saving tax". Anything that is more than your needs is your saving and you should pay some of it as Zakat.

زکوتہ ٹیکس نہیں عبادت ہے. ایسے عبادت سمجھ کر ادا کرنا چاہے ناکہ بوجھ

 

[salaudin]

Re: Islam doesn't allow to collect taxes

زکوتہ ٹیکس نہیں عبادت ہے. ایسے عبادت سمجھ کر ادا کرنا چاہے ناکہ بوجھ

Zakat aik farz ha, ibadat ka mujhay pata nahi. Farz boojh samajh kar to mainay nahi kaha keh aada karna chahyay aur na hi "tax" ko boojh samajh kar aada karna chahyay !

Bahar haal, Zakat aik "tax" ki tareef par poora utarta ha !

 

[atensari]

Re: Islam doesn't allow to collect taxes

Zakat aik farz ha, ibadat ka mujhay pata nahi. Farz boojh samajh kar to mainay nahi kaha keh aada karna chahyay aur na hi "tax" ko boojh samajh kar aada karna chahyay !

Bahar haal, Zakat aik "tax" ki tareef par poora utarta ha !

آپ زکوتہ کی جو مرضی تعریف کریں، عبادت ٹیکس نہیں ہوتی

 

[salaudin]

Re: Islam doesn't allow to collect taxes

آپ زکوتہ کی جو مرضی تعریف کریں، عبادت ٹیکس نہیں ہوتی

hazrat, yeh is qisam kay jumloon say koi baat sabit nahi hooti aapki.

Zakat farz ha, ibadat ka mujhay koi saboot nahi mila kabhi to men kuch nahi keh sakta. "Tax" har woh cheez ha jo aada karna lazmi ha to sharaan Zakat "Tax" ki tareef par poora utarta ha.

 

[atensari]

Re: Islam doesn't allow to collect taxes

hazrat, yeh is qisam kay jumloon say koi baat sabit nahi hooti aapki.

Zakat farz ha, ibadat ka mujhay koi saboot nahi mila kabhi to men kuch nahi keh sakta. "Tax" har woh cheez ha jo aada karna lazmi ha to sharaan Zakat "Tax" ki tareef par poora utarta ha.

آپ کے الفاظ سے ٹیکس بھی ثابت نہیں ہوتی