مریم نواز اپنی تقریر کا ایک ایک لفظ لاجک اور دلیری کے ساتھ بیان کرتی ہیں۔
- Thread starter Kashif Altaf
- Start date
Masud Rajaa
Siasat member
Sala Bharwa Banchod... Begarat
Yaar aap clearly Mian Saanp sahib ke Sehat se Jalte hoo. Very Bad
snowballpk
MPA (400+ posts)
Iss ka bhi Nigaar award banta hai 
Wake up Pak
(50k+ posts) بابائے فورم
BlackBirdSSG
Citizen
Timeline: How Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza’s Tone Evolved
| Period | Tone & Focus | Key Themes / Behavior |
|---|---|---|
| 2014–2018 |  Confrontational & Reformist | - Aggressively exposed sectarian scholars (Sunni, Shia, Deobandi, Barelvi) - Called out fabricated Hadith, weak scholarship - Criticized Maulana Tariq Jameel, Zakir Naik, etc. - Refused to align with any school of thought - Very anti-status quo, both religious and political |
| 2019–2021 |  Philosophical & Pan-Islamic | - Began calling for unity of Muslims, while continuing his critique - Balanced approach: would still name powerful figures, but also advocate understanding - Occasionally praised Imran Khan's “efforts” for Muslim world unity - Still seen as independent and neutral |
| 2022 |  Cautious but Critical | - Criticized Imran Khan's politics and other leaders - Warned against populism, cult-like following of political figures - Didn’t praise establishment but avoided naming army directly - After Imran’s ouster (Apr 2022), shifted toward “I told you so” narrative |
| 2023 (Post-May 9) |  Defensive & Pro-Establishment | - Sharp turn: harshly criticized PTI supporters - Portrayed May 9 protesters as irrational, disrespectful of army - Repeatedly defended Army Chief Asim Munir, calling him “a man of deen” - Started defending Maryam Nawaz’s development initiatives |
| 2024–2025 |  Controlled Commentary | - Became extremely soft on the military and PML-N - Ignores crackdown on dissent, rigging allegations, media blackout - Selectively targets PTI while praising establishment narratives - Openly aligned with “reform from within” stance regarding system |
Comparison with Other Religious Scholars
| Scholar | Stance on Imran Khan | Stance on Establishment | Public Image |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mufti Tariq Masood | Neutral-Critical |  Critical (indirectly) | Balanced but less political. Warns against military overreach and blind political following. Avoids naming names. |
| Israr Ahmad (Late) |  Supported Khan’s vision | Strongly anti-establishment | Legacy of ideological purity. Criticized both mullahs and generals. |
| Dr. Ghulam Hussain Sialvi | Pro-Khan | Anti-establishment | Has spoken clearly against military interference and election manipulation. |
| Allama Khadim Rizvi (Late) | Strongly anti-Khan (blasphemy row) | Seen as used by establishment | His movement was later seen as manipulated for political pressure. |
| Javed Ahmed Ghamidi | Very neutral | Clear institutional critic | Never aligned with power. Intellectual and reformist but doesn’t interfere in politics directly. |
| Engineer Ali Mirza | Harsh critic of Khan | Defends Army, praises Maryam Nawaz | Seen as shifting toward state-approved narrative, despite non-sectarian past. |
Key Differences
| Aspect | Engineer Ali Mirza | Others (e.g., Ghamidi, Sialvi, Tariq Masood) |
|---|---|---|
| Tone Post-May 9 | Echoes state narrative | Balanced or cautious criticism |
| Public Trust | Declining among anti-establishment circles | Relatively stable |
| Engagement with Political Crisis | Selective — avoids PML-N/Army criticism | More holistic (e.g., Ghamidi critiques both sides) |
| Accusations of Bias | Increasingly seen as compromised or scared | Others maintain perceived neutrality |
Islamabadiya
Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Youthio!
Thorda buhut bardasht kr liya karu
Tum logon ke forun he phat jateee hay
Thorda buhut bardasht kr liya karu
Tum logon ke forun he phat jateee hay
karachiwala
Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
tu bhi thoda bardashat kar liya kar. jahan baji ka naam ayya to tu forun bill me se munh nikal kar daant dikhata hae patwari
Islamabadiya
Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
wasiqjaved
Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Aye pai je Laaaaaaaaa'JHAK!
Abuse karay ga be kesay. Didiyan supply karnay walay ka begarat hona must ha.
YA BEYAN KUM AUR KHUSRA GEERI ZAYDA LUG RAHE HAY.
