Nabi kee sunnat say sabit kero kay jheenga haram hay ?
کیاجھینگاکھاناحلال ہے؟ Prawns Halal or Haram? by Mufti Tariq Masood
- Thread starter Deen Aasan
- Start date
-
- Tags
- mufti tariq masood
Nabi kee sunnat say sabit kero kay jheenga haram hay ?
hairatkada
Banned
Yeh Kia baat howi? Sawaal per Sawaal? I asked you for proof and you are unable to provide me one. I requested you to please present me one ayat or one hadith that states that Prawn is Halal. Can you provide that please?
hairatkada
Banned
I find it very Islamic and Logical. It is my personal choice. Amongst all the fiqh i have reviewed, Imaam Abou haneefa's fiqh comes out to be very solid and in accordance with quran and sunnah.
Bhai baaat samajhny ki koshech karoo.
is tarha to Quran o Hadith main BHANS ka bhi naaam kahin nahi hay phir ap kaho gay woh bhi HARAM hay ?
hairatkada
Banned
This is a very naive question, how about I ask you that u prove from sunnat that Rhino is haraam : I am sure that there is not a verse in quran about it , Would you now start eating Rhinos? lolz
Brother, the purpose is not to offend you but to make you realize that if something is not mentioned in quran, then it does not mean that it is halal. Rhinos, elephants, toads, frogs, crocks and shrimps are all haram. My advice to you is not to eat them. Why are u not satisfied with sheep, beef and fish? lol
aur is silsalay main ap nay kin kin Hanafi Kutab ko parha ? ya phir koi Imam abu hanifa ki kitab ka naam ?
hairatkada
Banned
This is a Bhainse also known as Buffalo
and this Below is Cow :
Cows and Buffalos are both Bovine animals and if one is Halal the other has to be Halal too.
But look at Fish and compare with Shirmp
This is fish and is halal
and this is shrimp or lobster :
EVEN A BLIND MAN CAN TELL THAT BOTH ARE NOT THE SAME SPECIE. SHRIMP belongs to phylum arthropod and is totally different in its biological classification. And this is why I follow Imaam Abou Haneefa caz he makes perfect sense as per quran and Sunnah!
hairatkada
Banned
Kitab to Prophet Muhammad ( PBUH) nay bhee koi nahi likhi...aap kehna kia chahtay ho? Likhi ho ya na likhi ho? what do u mean to say?
main nay pocha apn nay hanafi fiqh ko kahan kasy parha ?
hairatkada
Banned
Pehaly Jo may poch raha houn uska jawaab do. Baat Daleel say hogi or Asool say. Do not use diversions. Topic per baat kero please Jheengay, Geinday, Hathi or Bhainse per wapas aoo. Topic was Halaal Haraam. Why you want to divert?
chalain moamla ap k liyeh asaaan kar detta hoon sirf Hanfi Fiqh main hi prawns Halal nahi hain baqi 3 fiqh main halal hain.
aur baqoool hananfi ulama k sab fiqh HAQ pay hain to ap q baqi 3 Fiqh ko haq pay honay k bawajood nahi maan rahy ?
hairatkada
Banned
Is maslay per baqi fiqh say ijtehadi ghalati howi hay. That is why i like imaam abou haneefa more. Imaam Abou haneefa always had very solid opinion!
aur yeh solid opinions ap nay kon c kutab main parhein ?
hairatkada
Banned
Kitaboun ko choro....tum to ahlay hadith ho menay tumsay hadith mangi or quran kee ayat mangi kay give me one ayat from the quran or one hadith from sahih bukhari or sahih muslim that Shrimp is halal. So far you cannot give me one single reference. Kitaboun kee bari to baad may aye gee. Hujjat quran or hadith hay ! Give me example from quran or hadith. We will come to books later!
Believer12
Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
dog and pig to koi bhi nahi kha sakta.
hairatkada
Banned
yes but as per abu dujana logic her wo cheese jiss ko quran may haram declare na kia ho wo khaye jasakti hay. Thats why i mentioned cats and dogs because the quran does not mention that dogs and cats are haram...but we know that the islamic fiqh delcares them haram so we dont eat them.
