Ah more chatGPT cut and paste, lets get into in then.
1. Who preserved the Qur’an after the death of the Prophet (PBUH)?
- Using the Qur’an alone, can you name a single person who carried, memorized, or transmitted it?
Answered in my thread
Well the claim is often made that if you say the transmission of the hadith is problematic and has grave issues then in turn you are also saying that you have a problem with the transmission of the Quran also because it was done by the same people the same way. Lets look into that if it really is the case.
Anyone who says this first of all really doesn't understand how the Quran was transmitted. Quran was transmitted on mass by people, they taught it to their children they taught it to their neighbors they taught it to their friends people conveyed the message of the Quran before the...
2. Can you name anyone who had the Qur’an in their possession 1–5 years after the Prophet’s death?
Why do we need to know anyone's name?
3. How do you know the Qur’an wasn’t tampered with after the Prophet (PBUH) passed away?
Well as a Muslim you have faith and belief in Allah's book and everything that's in it when Allah says
75:17 We shall make sure of its safe collection and recitation.
As a believing Muslim that guarantee is enough for us.
4. Who compiled the Qur’an into a single mushaf?
Allah refers to the Quran as Al Kitab i.e The Book 261 times in the book meaning it was always meant to be in book form. No bits and pieces scattered about. The only reason you even believe it was not made into a Mushaf until the after the Prophet passed away was because of stories in the hadith. Once again the hadith insulting the prophet instigating the Messenger left the earth without doing so, he didn't complete his job for delivering to us the Al Kitaab. But you rather the Prophet be insulted rather than questions be raised on your precious hadith.
How was the Qur’an preserved before paper and printing?
Once again false beliefs because of the hadith and just lack of general knowledge to think text before the invention or arrival of paper was never written or there were no books. The Birmingham Manuscript clearly shows the Quran was available in book form during the Prophets lifetime give or take a few years.
6. What method do you use to verify the Qur’an’s verses without any isnād
Do you think Allah's book is dependent on your scholars defective methodology to prove its completeness and authenticity? As mentioned before for a believing Muslim it is Allah's guarantee is enough. Again another insult to the Quran to safeguard your precious hadith.
7. Can you show — from the Qur’an alone — how many chapters it has?
Just pick one up and count them all?
8. Why do all Muslims recite the same Fatiha and end with Surah An-Nas?
Because that's the way Allah wanted it to be and the messenger made sure of it.
9. How can you disprove the possibility that verses or surahs were removed?
Answered in my thread
Well the claim is often made that if you say the transmission of the hadith is problematic and has grave issues then in turn you are also saying that you have a problem with the transmission of the Quran also because it was done by the same people the same way. Lets look into that if it really is the case.
Anyone who says this first of all really doesn't understand how the Quran was transmitted. Quran was transmitted on mass by people, they taught it to their children they taught it to their neighbors they taught it to their friends people conveyed the message of the Quran before the...
AND
"Indeed, it is We who sent down the Qur'an, and indeed, We will be its guardian." Qur'an 15:9
10. If enemies of the Prophet (PBUH) existed (which the Qur’an confirms), how do you know they didn’t tamper with the text after he died?
See the answer to 1 and 9
11. Why would Allah protect the Qur’an but not give any names of those who preserved it?
Better question is why would he give any names in the first place?
12. Do you accept the story of Abu Bakr ordering the compilation of the Qur’an?
No
14. If the Qur’an is so “clear,” why do Quranists disagree among themselves about how to pray, fast, or pay zakat?
If the hadith explain the Quran then how come every sect disagree among themselves on even the finest of details, like how and where to keep your hands during your ritual salats, to say ameen loudly or quietly, to raise the hands or not to raise the hands. Let alone any major issues.
15. If you reject all hadith and all historical sources... how do you even know you’re holding the original Qur’an?
See answers to 1,9 and 10.
This is exactly why I started this thread
Well the claim is often made that if you say the transmission of the hadith is problematic and has grave issues then in turn you are also saying that you have a problem with the transmission of the Quran also because it was done by the same people the same way. Lets look into that if it really is the case.
Anyone who says this first of all really doesn't understand how the Quran was transmitted. Quran was transmitted on mass by people, they taught it to their children they taught it to their neighbors they taught it to their friends people conveyed the message of the Quran before the...
That people in order to defend their hadith from criticism are willing to throw the Quran and the Prophet wholesale under the bus rather than accept the massive deficiencies in the hadith transmission.
Like this futile attempt. They say the believe and have faith in the Quran but cannot trust or believe on Allah when he says in that its a Kitaab and that he is responsible for its protection. They rather believe that the messenger of Allah left the Quran in bits and pieces and tatters spread across the land on tree bark and bones or goats ate pages of the Quran and they were lost forever that's why there are no verses about stoning and breast feeding adults 10 times in the Quran. Yes that is an actual hadith printed till today from one of the 6 major books of hadith Sunan Ibn Majah.
Can you imagine the Prophet doing that or the Quran will have such filth like breast feeding an adult 10 times to make him a mahram? But no according to you the Quran contained such filth but goats ate those "pages" so now we have an incomplete Quran today. So leveling such blasphemy against the Quran is perfectly ok to you, but don't you dare question my blasphemous hadith.