Can some one tell me why is this happening?????

[sarbakaf]

Look at this pic of some mosque in islamabad(picture in khabrain news website today) name of mosque is not given
how come women are in same row as men? side by side
Can some one tell me if its islamic...........
or is it another act of modernization given to ISLAM by us pakistanis........

i will appreciate comments from ppl who know islamic verdict about this

 

[itsnotme90]

sorry i didnt see the full picture first coz it was only opening half on my screen so i could only see scarf and thats why i thought they r little children with their dad but now i saw the full pic thats really ridiculous

 

[rana14801]

as far as know women cannot offer prayers by sitting side by side but they can perfom at the end rows and that too saperately.and by face they r grown up women not look like girls.

 

[sarbakaf]

lol...
bro itsnotme

r u talking about mental age?
and is it mental age of girls or guyz....or both.......
coz physically these girls look like mothers of many 12 years old

 

[khalid100]

As per my knowledge of Islam, there must be segregation between men and women during the prayers. Only place where all of them are allowed is the Haram-e-Kaaba.
Even in Masjid Nabvi it is not allowed.
Now Allah knows the best as why they are doing it in that mosque in Islamabad!

 

[keamari12]

ISS BARAY MAIN MUKHTALIF FIRQOO MAIN IKHTILAAF HAI MAGAR ISS TARHA JO ISLBD MAIN HOO RAHA HAI KAHEE IJAZAT NAHEE

 

[y2sag]

READ THIS

Plz Come Out of enclosed vision.

what i notice is there is a gap in the men n women, secondly what i feel is that this masjid is faisal masjid, which is very huge n big, in that u cant put women at the end, as there is no end rows. yet u can do is put women area on one side, as it happens in MASJID AL HARAAM, i guess somebody is misleading us by using this pic.

 

[taggtow]

The picture doesn't look photoshop-ed.

 

[abbasiali]

READ THIS

Plz Come Out of enclosed vision.

what i notice is there is a gap in the men n women, secondly what i feel is that this masjid is faisal masjid, which is very huge n big, in that u cant put women at the end, as there is no end rows. yet u can do is put women area on one side, as it happens in MASJID AL HARAAM, i guess somebody is misleading us by using this pic.

Dear Y2sag,
For your information, women are allowed to pray in mosque, but they have to pray behind men, either in the last rows or separate area, but it has to be behind men area.

 

[abbasiali]

I have a very strong feeling, these are pretenders, not the actual muslims, None of mosque in Literate areas in Pakistan, permits women praying together with men,

People whom I can see in this picture, very much look like interior sindh or Turbat area, where there is cast growing, specially in Turbat, a month or couple of months before, Bolta Pakistan team has given a very brief report about their believe and life style, I feel like, these are the same people.

But if some one claims to be in Islamabad, no wonder, if these elements have penetrate in Capital. But I have my doubts about Capital.

Regards.

 

[takjhank]

awayen bongiaan naa maaro yar...

us news paper may aadhi khabar to news paper walay chupa gay hain...

which is...... ye namaz e jumma, Ahmadion ki ek masjid may hua hay jo k punjab k ek ruler area may waaqay hay....

ye news paper walay i don't know, adhoori baat ku kartay hain.. logo ko gumrah karnay k liye...

wesey islam may ladies or gents ko ekathay namaz parhna mana hay.... haan.. albatta, ladies mard hazraat k pichay ya phir alag jaga par jahan mardo or oraton k beech may parda ho. wahan namaz parh sakti hain... but.. side ba side nahi...


TJ

 

[keamari12]

ABBAS BHAEE KHAWATEEN KAY MASJID MAIN NAMAZ ADDA KARNAY YA NA KARNAY MAIN IKHTILAAF HAI MUKHTALIF FIQA MAIN AAP KEH RAHAY HAIN ISLAM MAIN ISS KI IJAAZAT HAI KIO AIK NAYA TANAZA KHARA KARNA CHAHTAY HAI

 

[Maxculine]

I agree that there is a conflict between IMAMS about women prayers in the mosque. Ideally , women should offer separately from men.

I am not an alim but if any conflict can be avoided then any such action should not have been taken.

If there is doubt on anything , we should not go ahead with that.
[fazl]

 

[abdulhaseeb23]

wese mardoo ke sath aurat namaz nahi pardh sakti albata peche ya alag jagah padh sakti hain different firqoo ka differnet aaqeda hai,, lekin aik bad app sab logon ki knowledge mein la doon ke yeh qadyaniyon mein jayaz hai balke aun mein tou yeh bhi jayaz hai ke aurat jamat bhi karwati rahi hai aur ain ka sab se barah sarbarah Maalol Salman Rushdi phele yeh haraqat kar chuka hai London mein

 

[mali70]

This has got to be a doctored Picture just to tease us. I cannot believe this can happen anywhere in Pakistan. Please varify these kinds of pictures before psoting it

Thanks

 

[laiq]

bhai logon yeh jo bhi hai, such ya jhoot, ibadat to usi ki ho rahi hai na jo is poori kainaat ka rub hai or jis kay qabzay mien hamari jaan hai or hum ko wapis usi ki taraf lotna hai, Allah Allah ho rahi hai bus yehi kaafi hai...

 

[y2sag]

@ ALI ABBASSI

IN masjid e haraam men pray behind women
tough the first row is of males, i.e. near qaaba wall
but right after that u see a mixture, group of ladies behind men, n then
group of men behind ladies.
Alhamdolillah i hv done umrah many many times, so i know this fact very well, at big masjids, how can u define an end of men row,
practically its not possible

 

[shaheedchoudry]

KHUDA KA SHUKAR ADA KARO. ROSHAN KHIAL MUSHARRAF IS GONE. OTHERWISE, WE WERE UP AGAIST ANOTHER DEEN -E-ILAHI.

 

[love_pakistan]

Shame on the people

shame on those people who are saying the

namaz of women and men is allowed toagther, i strongly condmen it, women can pray in the mosque but in seperate area or in the last row...with parda.................now i tel u y in the last row.......bcoz no men can see them and the modesty of parda shud be maintained n at the finish of namaz they moved quickly., otherwise y women is allowed to observe parda......parda not only mean to cover ur body but alos to protect ur self from evil eyes...

I share one thing........after the rikhlat (death) of Hazrar Muhammad (peace be upon him), Hazra Ayeshar(rz) stopped women to go to mosque once, some Sahbi(rz) came to Hazrar Ayesha(rz) and asked the reason bcoz Aap(peace be upon him) allowed the womon to pray in mosque but seperately,

Hazrat Ayeshar(rz) replied , i know but i think if Aap(peace be upon him) had alive, he(peace be upon him) would have stop to the women bcoz of ZAMANA FITNA MEAN zaman e fitna kii wajah saa mein naa rooka........

and for ur kind information , there is no difference in any of sect abt this issue it is not allowed , i feel immense sorry that v all r now only muslim b name.........i m not naik muslim but i know basics and clear abt the boundaries.........
there cud be differene in opinion in ahmedi, marzai......but they r not muslim

 

[schez]

Re: Shame on the people

salam all......

well said SIASAT..... i was wondering how could ppl justify this act as islamic or giving dere suggestions tht men & women can offer prayers together... there is a clear way what has been told ... & its really pity that we muslims specially from Pakistan doesnt even knw these basics principles... i absolutely agree wid you... there is no second thought on that..... i hope every1 shoulld think atleast 1 time before making comments on such issues.....