Do we need a Ruiet Hilal committee?

[Shareef]

With a cry for austerity and sensibility being cry of the day, we should seriously consider if we need a Ruiet Hilal committee at all. Scientific advancement tells us exactly position of the moon at any time and any body or few people who testify seeing the moon accordingly and call a number set for it, the announcement should be made without any further fuss and spending millions for the meeting. The other simple option could be to coordinate with Khana kaaba for the purpose. No hassle, no controversies and no wastage of money will happen.

 

[Zulu76]

With a cry for austerity and sensibility being cry of the day, we should seriously consider if we need a Ruiet Hilal committee at all. Scientific advancement tells us exactly position of the moon at any time and any body or few people who testify seeing the moon accordingly and call a number set for it, the announcement should be made without gathering mullas of diverse shades on that day and spending millions for the meeting. The other simple option could be to coordinate with Khana kaaba for the purpose. No hassle, no controversies and no wastage of money will happen.

NOOOO.

 

[ranaji]

یہ ایک سیاسی ہڈی ُاور راتب ہے جو ہر حکومت کتوں کو ڈالتی ہے اپنے حق میں بھونکنے کے لئے

 

[asifukp]

its more like a" Ruiet Haram Committee". a big NO.

 

[Champion 01]

ویسے کیا کمال کی روٹی لگی ہوئ ہے ان ملاؤں کی۔

 

[Meme]

A more relevant question would be, do we need a PM?

https://twitter.com/x/status/1517121817936535552

 

[Islamabadiya]

A more relevant question would be, do we need a PM?

https://twitter.com/x/status/1517121817936535552

damn thats a lot

 

[Wake up Pak]

 

[Wake up Pak]

 

[Citizen X]

Please don't try to show patwaris a mirror. They don't like it, its like showing a vampire, a crucifix!

 

[Wake up Pak]

Please don't try to show patwaris a mirror. They don't like it, its like showing a vampire, a crucifix!

Yaar inn baygherat patwarioon ko mirror kiya jutay bhi maro tu koi asar nahi hota.

 

[Citizen X]

Yaar inn baygherat patwarioon ko mirror kiya jutay bhi maro tu koi asar nahi hota.

Wohi toh, is liye apna time kyu barbaad kerte ho in kutti nasal per. I've blocked around 95% patwaris. Don't have any time to listen to their worthless bullshit. And I'm contemplating blocking a few more patwari cockroaches who have crawled out of their gutters recently.

 

[Wake up Pak]

Wohi toh, is liye apna time kyu barbaad kerte ho in kutti nasal per. I've blocked around 95% patwaris. Don't have any time to listen to their worthless bullshit. And I'm contemplating blocking a few more patwari cockroaches who have crawled out of their gutters recently.

Kabhi kabi inko in he key zaban may doze dayni parti hay kiyonkay yeah patwari yahan as usual jhoot aur makkarai say gumrah karnay key koshish kar tay hain iss liyay may nay inko block nahi kiya. Laykin ab souch raha hoon dou aik ko dust bin may dalnay kay liyay

 

[Citizen X]

Kabhi kabi inko in he key zaban may doze dayni parti hay kiyonkay yeah patwari yahan as usual jhoot aur makkarai say gumrah karnay key koshish kar tay hain iss liyay may nay inko block nahi kiya. Laykin ab souch raha hoon dou aik ko dust bin may dalnay kay liyay

You cannot shine a turd no matter how much you polish it, it belongs in the gutter.

 

[khipk]

With a cry for austerity and sensibility being cry of the day, we should seriously consider if we need a Ruiet Hilal committee at all. Scientific advancement tells us exactly position of the moon at any time and any body or few people who testify seeing the moon accordingly and call a number set for it, the announcement should be made without any further fuss and spending millions for the meeting. The other simple option could be to coordinate with Khana kaaba for the purpose. No hassle, no controversies and no wastage of money will happen.

One of very few things that I admire Fawwad Chaudry for is openly challenging the need of Reut-e-Hilal committee.
They dont mind using scientific knowledge for Sehri and Iftar timings, but with moon sighting they insist on manual sighting. Khair if they want to keep it as tradition it can be ok. because the whole regional sighting doesn't make sense to me. If today Pakistan and Afghanistan join together and make a single country, then sighting in Kabul only would mean a Eid for Karachi and Lahore people, but because politically its a different country, the Eid in Karachi and Lahore is one day late. WTF!!! The start of Ramzan, Eid and LailaTulQadar night for eastern Pakistan all depends on whether Pakistan and Afghanistan are two separate political countries or one. wow!!


Turkish model is the best one, and living in Europe I follow them. Not only they follow the scientific calculation, they go for global sighting. wherever the new moon appears, the next day is Eid for Turks and their affiliated countries all over the world. Simple. No jhanjat no nonsense.