End Game in Afghanistan
Posted on 01. Jul, 2011 by drmuzaffar in Af-Pak
The United States has never admitted defeat; this is perfectly in line with its self-image. No super power can ridicule the very notion of its superness by admitting defeat. This unwillingness, however, does not change the verdict of history: Vietnam was a humiliating affair; Iraq has been a mixed situation, Bush was able to remove Saddam Hussein but that led to the emergence of the first Shia dominated Arab state in modern history and no one knows how this will change the entire Middle East equation.
By Dr. Muzaffar Iqbal
The United States has never admitted defeat; this is perfectly in line with its self-image. No super power can ridicule the very notion of its superness by admitting defeat. This unwillingness, however, does not change the verdict of history: Vietnam was a humiliating affair; Iraq has been a mixed situation, Bush was able to remove Saddam Hussein but that led to the emergence of the first Shia dominated Arab state in modern history and no one knows how this will change the entire Middle East equation.
Afghanistan is, however, neither Vietnam nor Iraq. Thus when President Barack Obama admitted that American involvement in Afghanistan is no more financially viablethough not in these wordshe admitted defeat, albeit American style. For an American president to admit what he admitted, after ten long years, is another characteristic American attitude toward the dictates of history: what was said after ten long years, was already known to everyone without the expense of 500 billion dollars: no one has been able to rule that rugged country where the inhabitants fight outsiders as a profession carried from father to son down the centuries. Afghanistan remained defiant to the British colonizers, it proved to be an impossible land for the Soviets and now the Americans are making plans to leave.
President Obama is making no concession to the Afghans in his decision to pull back American troops; he has his second term as the most obvious personal consideration and he has Americas economy as the national consideration. Furthermore, in making his announcement against the desires of his generals, he has proven one more time that America is a country with an army, not an army with a country, as is the case for Pakistan. Wars are hugely costly and after ten years, what America has accomplished in Afghanistan is no more than what any other occupier has accomplished since history started to record the chronicles of that wonderful land where people live with an unquenchable thirst for freedom.
One must admit that the ragtag Taliban have proven one more time that faith is stronger than weapons; that no one, not even the lone superpower, can overcome those who possess faith. All that Taliban have to do now is bid time, continue to do what they are doing and the future is theirs. What would they make of that future remains to be seen but one thing is clear: the newly trained Afghan army will collapse like a house of cards and they will simply sweep through the country just like they did last time. If they have gained any wisdom, they will make much more of their victory this time around.
Before we get to that point, however, there are numerous ifs and buts. To be sure, the puppet regime will want to prolong its hold. It will offer permanent bases to the departing occupiers; it will raise a lot of helpless cries about the future of the country, but none of this is unknown to the Americans; they know what could not be achieved with $500 billion and 130,000 soldiers will not be achievable with a fraction of that amount both in money and in troops. In addition, even the most protected military base will always remain an easy target of a resurgent Taliban force.
No matter what decision America eventually makes, the entire equation is about to change because the hen laying golden eggs will depart and with it, a most ludicrous business for the generals in Afghanistan and Pakistan will come to an end; nothing lasts forever, so no one should complain; it was good for as long as it lasted. They must now find another paymaster.
In a world dominated by green buck, no one is going to talk about the human cost of this war, especially for the Afghans. To be sure, the country has been destroyed and its population has been traumatized. No one has been counting non-white dead bodies. So, no one really knows the cost of war to the Afghans, but with their faith stronger than the mighty mountains which enclose this beautiful land, their wounds will heal in good time and their villages will gain a degree of tranquility and stability, although it may take a generation before the delicious Qandhari pomegranates fully recover.
American pullout from Afghanistan has tremendous challenges for Pakistan. If all goes well, by 2014, Pakistan would have already be in the hands of a second civilian government after the long military rule which had Americanized it. The authority of the generals would have further weakened and hopefully, there will be a way to reconfigure Pakistans political, economic and military priorities in the wake of American withdrawal from Afghanistan. It has been so long that it is almost impossible to imagine Pakistans main security and military agenda without the Afghan war. But one must attempt to foresee possible scenarios.
Without a war in Afghanistan and with a reduced animosity with India, Pakistan can drastically cut its defense spending. A wise and stable civilian government may be able to curtail the power of generals. This power can only be curtailed if there is a strong civilian rule and the judiciary is autonomously functioning. A strong civilian rule requires a very representative parliament not beholden to a lion of Punjab or Sindh and that is exactly Pakistan is lacking since its birth: it has failed to evolve a political culture which is independent of a political lord. Just like Afghanistan cannot function without war lords, Pakistan has never been able to function without political lords.
There is, thus, an urgent need for a few individuals to come forward and attempt to establish a mechanism through which a new political force can come into existence. All the factors are in place for this new force to evolve: a relatively young and educated population, a chronic political disorder; a sense of hopelessness which can be converted into an action plan, and an opportunity the like of which has never existed before as people are now sick and tired of the faces which have dominated Pakistans politics for as long as one can remember.
Source:-http://www.opinion-maker.org/2011/07/end-game-in-afghanistan/
Posted on 01. Jul, 2011 by drmuzaffar in Af-Pak
The United States has never admitted defeat; this is perfectly in line with its self-image. No super power can ridicule the very notion of its superness by admitting defeat. This unwillingness, however, does not change the verdict of history: Vietnam was a humiliating affair; Iraq has been a mixed situation, Bush was able to remove Saddam Hussein but that led to the emergence of the first Shia dominated Arab state in modern history and no one knows how this will change the entire Middle East equation.By Dr. Muzaffar Iqbal
The United States has never admitted defeat; this is perfectly in line with its self-image. No super power can ridicule the very notion of its superness by admitting defeat. This unwillingness, however, does not change the verdict of history: Vietnam was a humiliating affair; Iraq has been a mixed situation, Bush was able to remove Saddam Hussein but that led to the emergence of the first Shia dominated Arab state in modern history and no one knows how this will change the entire Middle East equation.
Afghanistan is, however, neither Vietnam nor Iraq. Thus when President Barack Obama admitted that American involvement in Afghanistan is no more financially viablethough not in these wordshe admitted defeat, albeit American style. For an American president to admit what he admitted, after ten long years, is another characteristic American attitude toward the dictates of history: what was said after ten long years, was already known to everyone without the expense of 500 billion dollars: no one has been able to rule that rugged country where the inhabitants fight outsiders as a profession carried from father to son down the centuries. Afghanistan remained defiant to the British colonizers, it proved to be an impossible land for the Soviets and now the Americans are making plans to leave.
President Obama is making no concession to the Afghans in his decision to pull back American troops; he has his second term as the most obvious personal consideration and he has Americas economy as the national consideration. Furthermore, in making his announcement against the desires of his generals, he has proven one more time that America is a country with an army, not an army with a country, as is the case for Pakistan. Wars are hugely costly and after ten years, what America has accomplished in Afghanistan is no more than what any other occupier has accomplished since history started to record the chronicles of that wonderful land where people live with an unquenchable thirst for freedom.
One must admit that the ragtag Taliban have proven one more time that faith is stronger than weapons; that no one, not even the lone superpower, can overcome those who possess faith. All that Taliban have to do now is bid time, continue to do what they are doing and the future is theirs. What would they make of that future remains to be seen but one thing is clear: the newly trained Afghan army will collapse like a house of cards and they will simply sweep through the country just like they did last time. If they have gained any wisdom, they will make much more of their victory this time around.
Before we get to that point, however, there are numerous ifs and buts. To be sure, the puppet regime will want to prolong its hold. It will offer permanent bases to the departing occupiers; it will raise a lot of helpless cries about the future of the country, but none of this is unknown to the Americans; they know what could not be achieved with $500 billion and 130,000 soldiers will not be achievable with a fraction of that amount both in money and in troops. In addition, even the most protected military base will always remain an easy target of a resurgent Taliban force.
No matter what decision America eventually makes, the entire equation is about to change because the hen laying golden eggs will depart and with it, a most ludicrous business for the generals in Afghanistan and Pakistan will come to an end; nothing lasts forever, so no one should complain; it was good for as long as it lasted. They must now find another paymaster.
In a world dominated by green buck, no one is going to talk about the human cost of this war, especially for the Afghans. To be sure, the country has been destroyed and its population has been traumatized. No one has been counting non-white dead bodies. So, no one really knows the cost of war to the Afghans, but with their faith stronger than the mighty mountains which enclose this beautiful land, their wounds will heal in good time and their villages will gain a degree of tranquility and stability, although it may take a generation before the delicious Qandhari pomegranates fully recover.
American pullout from Afghanistan has tremendous challenges for Pakistan. If all goes well, by 2014, Pakistan would have already be in the hands of a second civilian government after the long military rule which had Americanized it. The authority of the generals would have further weakened and hopefully, there will be a way to reconfigure Pakistans political, economic and military priorities in the wake of American withdrawal from Afghanistan. It has been so long that it is almost impossible to imagine Pakistans main security and military agenda without the Afghan war. But one must attempt to foresee possible scenarios.
Without a war in Afghanistan and with a reduced animosity with India, Pakistan can drastically cut its defense spending. A wise and stable civilian government may be able to curtail the power of generals. This power can only be curtailed if there is a strong civilian rule and the judiciary is autonomously functioning. A strong civilian rule requires a very representative parliament not beholden to a lion of Punjab or Sindh and that is exactly Pakistan is lacking since its birth: it has failed to evolve a political culture which is independent of a political lord. Just like Afghanistan cannot function without war lords, Pakistan has never been able to function without political lords.
There is, thus, an urgent need for a few individuals to come forward and attempt to establish a mechanism through which a new political force can come into existence. All the factors are in place for this new force to evolve: a relatively young and educated population, a chronic political disorder; a sense of hopelessness which can be converted into an action plan, and an opportunity the like of which has never existed before as people are now sick and tired of the faces which have dominated Pakistans politics for as long as one can remember.
Source:-http://www.opinion-maker.org/2011/07/end-game-in-afghanistan/
