Kya Namaz me sirf Farz Parh Lena Kafi Hai ? Sunnat Mokadda Lazmi ?

[Amal]

 

[PLMNDAKOOPARTY.]

shoot the thread starter. What Ignorant retards.

 

[Shareef]

Well done Engineer. We need such ulema who try to give simple solutions within the ambit of sharia. For example In Pakistan, people who are sick or travelling are not allowed to eat during Ramzan and are looked down upon by the society. No hotel is open on highways. This is against the teaching of Islam. If Allah Almighty has made our religion easy why do mullahs make it so difficult?

 

[Wake up Pak]

Mullah nay Deen kay saath jo khilwar kiya hay woh kisi gunnah say kam nahi.
Stick to the Quran alone rest are just man-made books written some 200+ years after the demise of Hazrat Mohammad (SAW) based on conjecture and hearsay only.

 

[Wake up Pak]

 

[Wake up Pak]

Do good; indeed, Allah loves the doers of good #Quran 2:195

 

[Dream Seller]

Do good; indeed, Allah loves the doers of good #Quran 2:195

You’re just a misguided person who believes that Sunnah isn’t essential. Quran doesn’t give the details of the Fiqh of the Salah, how would have you understood if not Sunnah? Or you wouldn’t just follow anything that’s not detailed in Quran?

 

[Wake up Pak]

You’re just a misguided person who believes that Sunnah isn’t essential. Quran doesn’t give the details of the Fiqh of the Salah, how would have you understood if not Sunnah? Or you wouldn’t just follow anything that’s not detailed in Quran?

I won't follow anything that is not in the Quran as the Quran is detailed and complete.
I was misguided once just like you all hadeeth followers but, Allah has guided me towards the only authentic book, Al Quran.

 

[atensari]

صلات/صلی/صلوه کا یہ مفہوم تاریخ میں پہلی مرتبہ کب بیان ہوا، کس نے بیان کیا؟​

 

[Wake up Pak]

The problem with the majority of Muslims is that they have shunned the mental capacity of thinking, reflecting and reasoning based on their God-given intellect.
They are what they say in Urdu "LAKEER KAY FAQEER"

 

[atensari]

کسی اے بی سی کی تخلیق کو شئیر کرکے دوسروں کو سوچنے، سمجھنے کی صلاحیت سے محروم قرار دینے والوں کی اپنی سوچ اور سمجھ گھاس چرنے گئی ہے ورنہ وہ خود قرآن مجید پر سوچ بچار کرتے​

 

[Wake up Pak]

I am not here to argue with anyone and i am not stopping anyone from namaz as your emotions and feelings are attached to it.
99% of Muslims don't even know what they are reciting in the namaz.

 

[Yaldarum]

Well done Engineer. We need such ulema who try to give simple solutions within the ambit of sharia. For example In Pakistan, people who are sick or travelling are not allowed to eat during Ramzan and are looked down upon by the society. No hotel is open on highways. This is against the teaching of Islam. If Allah Almighty has made our religion easy why do mullahs make it so difficult?

I dont know what kind of human mutant you are. If you ever open your eyes in Ramzan in Pakistan then you'll see that food shops are open in all traveling related areas such as Airports, railways Stations and Bus Stops. However the general market is kept close as people CAN eat and have meals in their homes.

Issue is that inside you hate Islam but cant say it openly so you try to make fun of Ulema. If you are so sick of it, you are free to change your religion, dont worry you wont be persecuted in Pakistan.

As far as the thread and thread starter goes, Highly immature and partial information. This person is spreading confusion through bringing the selected text. Just give you an example, in Quran Salat (Namaz) is forbidden, but everyone knows that this with certain circumstances. This idiot just picks up part of source and spread it.

Remember two things while infering and understanding "injunctions"

1. Complete and all sources related to certain "hukm" or Nass
2. Nasikh and Mansookh

 

[Yaldarum]

Mullah nay Deen kay saath jo khilwar kiya hay woh kisi gunnah say kam nahi.
Stick to the Quran alone rest are just man-made books written some 200+ years after the demise of Hazrat Mohammad (SAW) based on conjecture and hearsay only.

Your analogy and argument is totally baseless.

 

[Wake up Pak]

Your analogy and argument is totally baseless.

It doesn't bother me what you think.

 

[Yaldarum]

It doesn't bother me what you think.

Keep your freedom to yourself and dont even try to humiliate and discuss about our scholars, specially when academically and professionally you are not qualified.

 

[Wake up Pak]

Keep your freedom to yourself and dont even try to humiliate and discuss about our scholars, specially when academically and professionally you are not qualified.

I will do what i think is right beside, it is an open forum and you don't own the right to it so don't tell me what to write or what not to.
I know how academic and professional these devil mullah's are.

 

[Yaldarum]

I will do what i think is right beside, it is an open forum and you don't own the right to it so don't tell me what to write or what not to.
I know how academic and professional these devil mullah's are.

Open firm doesnt allow you to bash out whatever you think. This forum is for discussion so if you cant tolerate any academic point then revert back to your ignorance..

As far as Ulema are concerns, you were exposed to few illiterate ones, which are in every profession. Not every surgeon, doctor and teacher is best, but we give due regard to respective fields.

 

[Citizen X]

Believe it or not I've watched this long ass video and many more from this Quran alone guy. His meanings makes absolutely make no sense. If you subsitute his meaning of the word salat and zaqah every place it is mentioned in the Quran it makes absolutely no sense.

And question to you lets say he is right but still someone prays times a day, what is wrong with that? According to him and many others like him. Salat means coming toghter to following closely or to create a bond. So what do you think people are doing 5 times a day? If not creating a bond with the Almighty.

P.S : I read the book you mentioned, Sense and Sensibility In Islam, boy what a massive waste of time. Nauzubilah Felt more like a parody of the Quran than anything else

 

[Citizen X]

I won't follow anything that is not in the Quran as the Quran is detailed and complete.

Well the Quran tell us to follow the Sunnah as mentioned in the Quran which I have pointed out to you from with in the Quran and you don't follow the Quran in that regards, which unfortunately would make you a hypocrite. You'll follow and believe any version of the Quran as long as you don't have to put in any effort from your end.

My theory is you lot are lazy Muslims, don't want to put in any effort, just pretend to be nice and do lovey dovey things and think that all that is required to be a good Muslim.