The Messiah: Why Islam is right and and Qadiyaniyat, Judism and Christianity is Wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.

TechWarrior

MPA (400+ posts)
Not many Muslims know about the word Messiah or Maseeh nor they seems to care about it. In Quran it is used for only one prophet, ISA A.S.
Almost in every religion there is a concept of battle between Good vs Evil that will going to happen near end times. Masih(Christ) and Masih Dajjal (AntiChrist) will face each other and finally Dajjal will be killed.

When you start doing comparative religion study you start to realize how important is the role of the messiah as Abrahamic religions are mostly divided because of this fact.

Jews at the time of Hazrat ISA A.S were waiting for messiah to come and fulfill the prophecies foretold in their scriptures (old testament). Despite seeing so much miracles and everything from ISA A.S they refused him as messiah as he according to them didn't fulfill all of the prophecies including one of the prophecy that messiah will rule the world. They knew that If we are able to kill ISA A.S, he cannot be a messiah as messiah cannot be killed until he rule the world and create future age of perfection which will unite humanity as one.

One thing is clear from Jews perspective, Messiah cannot die before fulfilling the prophecies.

As per Quran, ISA A.S was indeed messiah. The Jews at that time didn’t identify him because of their own wrongdoings. Allah raised him up alive and saved him from crucifixion when Jews tried to kill him.

Let us analyze this whole concept from all Abrahamic religion and Qadiyaniat perspective to better understand the logical reason why Islam is true in every way regarding messiah and ISA A.S.

Jews: Waiting for the messiah since more than 2000 years. They rejected Jesus but to this day they still cry for their messiah to come who will rule the world.

Christians: Christians like Muslims believe some of the prophecies will be fulfilled after ISA A.S return. They accepted ISA A.S as messiah but they believe he gave his life for the sake of mankind sin, this way he saved everyone who believe in this ultimate sacrifice that he gave on crucifixion.
For argument sake if ISA A.S died on the cross as per Christians, then Jews were right in crucifying him as ISA A.S didn’t fulfil many Old testament prophecies including the ruling over the world.


Qadiyanis: The whole messiah concept is almost like demolished which was totally inlined in case of Judism, Christianity and Islam. They say ISA A.S died in Kashmir and then Mirza Ghulam was also messiah and ISA A.S and he died also. So messiah died two times without doing any prophecies that were foretold.

Islam: Allah saved ISA A.S from crucification by not crucifying him on the cross and he will return as Messiah and kill AntiChrist and will do his unfinished job of ruling the world for 40 years (as per one of the Hadith). Allah will never break his promise of the prophecy he gave to “Sabqa Ummat-e Muslima”. Messiah has to come and he has to do his job before dying. Otherwise he cannot be a messiah if he dies before fulfilling his job. That is why he was raised up alive so that he can perform unfinished job.

Now if you see Jews position they rejected the real messiah and on Christ return, they will do the same and accept Anti-Christ as their Christ/Messiah.
Christians whole concept of sacrifice and ISA A.S dying doesn't make any sense as Jews can argue that we crucified messiah and he didn’t fulfill our prophecies we have to wait for another messiah to come.
Qadiyaniyat is totally exposed and contradicting all the religions in this concept.

Islam is the only religion in the world which makes perfect sense of messiah concept and fulfilling of the prophecies Jews were looking for. As per Islam ISA A.S has not died and will return and perform the prophecies already foretold in bible(Old Testament).

And Allah knows best.


 
Last edited by a moderator:

Vitamin_C

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
All religions are man-made and a product of mans own egos and imaginations. We have the exact same organs that other mammals have only difference is that some of them operate differently for every species of the mammal.

The idea of Abrahamic religions that the messiah or mehdi will come and every thing will be destroyed is a dangerous idea. If the world will die in a heat death after few trillion years thats not our business what our business should be is to make it a better place for everyone whether he is secular, muslim, jew, capitalist, keynesian or whatever stupid idealogy that people would subscribe to. Every language or religion we have today will be completely extinct in 10,000 years. So its better that we look beyond our own nose and our own ideologies that we were born with in our homes and focus on humanity and try to make the world a better place. Ideologies is the reason why wars happened. Fascism vs Communism, Christianity vs Islam. How about say we are all humans regardless of which color of unicorn we believe in
 

Subh e Nau

Politcal Worker (100+ posts)

It is interesting that the concept of the Masih for most Muslims is almost literally supernatural and superhuman in nature. Defying the physical and scientific laws of God in this universe that wasn't even provided to the greatest Prophet (saw). How far to the deep end have Muslims fallen that their view for the most part is literally a Bloody masih not a spiritual Masih.


@TechWarrior

 

TechWarrior

MPA (400+ posts)

It is interesting that the concept of the Masih for most Muslims is almost literally supernatural and superhuman in nature. Defying the physical and scientific laws of God in this universe that wasn't even provided to the greatest Prophet (saw). How far to the deep end have Muslims fallen that their view for the most part is literally a Bloody masih not a spiritual Masih.


@TechWarrior


@Subh e Nau



Now please answer me following question.

1) Why supernature/miracles cannot happen. Dont you believe in Miracle birth Of ISA A.S? Don't you believe that he raised people from dead by Allah permission? Where is your Science here?
2) Dajjal will also be spiritual AntiChrist?
3) Throughout Islamic History that includes (Judism and Christianity) there always have been concept of Messiah and this is going on for more than 2000 years. You think Jews, Christians and Muslims are crazy that they are crying for the coming of their messiah?

More Questions will be followed after you response.

Thanks
 

Subh e Nau

Politcal Worker (100+ posts)
@Subh e Nau

1) Why supernature/miracles cannot happen. Dont you believe in Miracle birth Of ISA A.S? Don't you believe that he raised people from dead by Allah permission? Where is your Science here?

Science has proven that indeed the birth of Jesus Son of Mary AS was a miracle but it was well within the ambit of laws of nature. Read for yourself as it is a sensitive issue.

2) Dajjal will also be spiritual AntiChrist?
What is Dajjal ? Sonething metaphorical or Jahileen awaiting a flying Khotaa as they are Khota themselves ? Everything can be taken literally ?

3) Throughout Islamic History that includes (Judism and Christianity) there always have been concept of Messiah and this is going on for more than 2000 years. You think Jews, Christians and Muslims are crazy that they are crying for the coming of their messiah?
Everyone awaits a Messiah. Nothing wrong. Bloody Messiah is the issue. Did Mohammad Pbuh kill pigs ? Tarnish cross churches ? Jesus Son of Mary is Dead as per Quran. Watch Javed Ahmad Ghamdi videos. So it is established that it won't be Dead Messiah. Prophet Jesus was Messiah after Prophet Moses. Prophet Mohammed was a Messiah after Prophet Jesus. So again a Messiah is awaited after Prophet Mohammed Pbuh as hinted in Surah e Al Araf verse 35. But not the dead One.



This is a huge concern.

1. See the World os dripping with Blood and they await a Bloody Messiah ? Are Holy Divine figures like this ? Aesa Zaalim tou na he aaey tou behtarr.

2. Quran categorically mentions Jesus Son of Mary As to be a Prophet for the Nation of Bani Israel. Is the Entire World Bani Israel ?

3. Prophet Pbuh as per Bukhari said that Messiah of Islam of later days which suspend Jehaad of Sword as that won't be needed. Read " یضح الحرب " hadith and here they await a bloody Messiah which is contrary to Bukhari Hadith.

4. Bukhari mentions the complexion, height, hair texture, physique of Messiah Son of Mary As aswell as Messiah of later days and both are totally different personalities in appearance. One is Pinkish white while other has wheatish complexion. Had it been Messiah of Bani Israel than He would have had same physique height complexion and not a totally diffetent one.There are more than 5 Ahadith of Bukhari.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top