That’s the best you have come up with. Do you, let me say again DO YOU UNDER STAND SIMPLE PLAIN ENGLISH??????????. I told you I WAS one of you and I know these tactics of avoiding the real issue. I will not fall for it. I am asking you about how the day begins you are telling me how the night fell.
Please don't try to become my daad yahan equality pe baat kr saktey ho to behtr he me aap se lecture leney nhi aya agr aapko lecture deney ka shoke he ya ye samhajtey ho k aap barey naik perhaizgaar or aalim ho to apney paas rakho mujhey aapki zaat aapke aamal aapke ilm se kuch lena dena nhi sambhal k rakho apney paas.jo insaan k paas hota he vo nazar ajata he apney mun mia mitho ban ney ki koshish na kro i dont think isey koi morally acha samjha jata he..................
You don't know me who i am what i think and you are saying you were one of us ......sounds stupid how can you say that..............even if you consider me a barelvi (which i don't) if you were a barelvi than why the hell are you telling me that is that going to change the truth.
tactics............apney garebaan me daikho kia stupid sawal kiaey hain tum ne sirf apnee zati bughz ki vaja se ore baat kr rahey ho tactics ki.
"ouron ko nasiat khud mian fasiat"
jao ja kr deobandion ki kitabain parho unkey khabo se bhari hoee hain................
"jinkey apney ghar sheeshey k hoon unhain doosro k ghar pathar nhi marney chahien"
jisko "night fell" ka pata ho usey "day begins" ka b pata ho ga thori science b parh letey to raat din k mutallik kuch maloom ho jata.
If someone only asks about how the "day begins" avoids how the "night falls" then you can understand how educated that person is ,or what motive that person has in his mind.
Let me share a similar incident with you which will help you understand your real problem.
I was in discussion with a die-hard barelvi, in a gathering. All of a sudden he came up with this; “Ahle Hadees are Ahle ----” (I don’t want to mention that)
I asked him What about Barlevi they do Shirk, Bidats and qabir parasti what do you call them Maha --------.”
Immidiatley he replied Hazarat Ali Hajeveri (RA) Was a Hanafi/Sunni (see his tactics how he moved from Barelvism to Hanafi and Sunnism, which I believe barelvi’s have nothing to do with Hanafiism) so u are calling him that. I said Naozo Billah how can u utter that words for some one because of whom I am muslim today.
Than I used the same tactics as yours, (relating something that was irrelevant but what can I do, it’s a saying Do as the Romans do when in Rome)
I asked him, Ahle Hadees do the Rafaideen, and Hazarat Ghulam Qadir Jillani (RA) did the refaideen in his entire life that means indirectly you said same thing against him, or for that matter your Ghaus Pak. That day till today he never argued with me again. Coming back on the topic.
Totally irrelevant ..................
No argument can be based on a self written story.........
isterha ki
norey ore
gaamey ki me aapko kaiee kahania suna deta hoo jiska maqsad
"AAPNEY AAP KO BARA AALIM FAZIL ZAHIR KRNA OR MUKHALIF KO GHATIA ORE JAHIL SABIT KRNA HO"
hasiat kia he is kahani ki............kisi daleel pe baat krain koi solid argument ho......isterha ki farzi kahanio se koi cheez sabit nhi hotee.....
Let me show you what I asked and what you replied. Print it out and take it to your teacher see if he gives any marks on it.
I think you need a teacher maulana jahil sahab zara ghore krain ye khaawab he haqeeqat nhi me ne aapko hawala b dia tha hazrat yousaf a.s k wakiey ka jis me misr k badshah ne khwab dekha tha.
Koi aik hadyt koi aik Quranic reference le aien jis se aap isko ghalat sabit kr sakain.
Q1) Hadarat Muhammad SWM needs this -adri's assistant to buy return ticket to Madina?
A1)In reply to your first question i ask you Does Allah needs your assistance to spread his religion.Does Allah needs angel's assistance to do all the work.I hope you would have understood the flaw in your question.this objection is invalid.
Aalim Fazil sahab agar aap meree sawal ka jawab detey to vohi aapkey sawal ka jawab b tha.
Mujhey herat hotee he aik taraf to aap argue kr rahey hain k Huzur s.a.w ko tahir ul qadri ki assistance ki zroorat kaisey parh gaiey(.............ye zehn me rakhtey hoey k ye wakia khwaab ka he.) lakin doosri taraf aap is baat pe kion sawal nhi uthatey k Allah ko farishto ki zroorat kion parh gaiee ???????????? KIA ALLAH hr cheez pe Qadir nhi.
Tahir ul qadri sahab k khawab ka to abi zikr hoa kia is se pehley isterha k sawal kion nhi pochey jatey ye bacho vali logicain na larao..............k hava pattey ko hilatee he Ya Allah hilata he...........grade 5 k baad b kuch parh letey to behtr tha.
Khud to jesey pedaishee haq le kr aiey ho sawal krney k hmain sawal krna mana he .......................tumharee adato se lagta he police valey ho sirf pochney k aadee ho.......vesey b jawab deney k liaey kuch ilm chahiey hota he.
Q2) He SWM needs him to be his host for food and shelter?
A2-I think you are trying to mix things by using the word "need".better word would be "wants" .
AAlim Fazil sahab ye khawb he pata nhi aap k sarr pe kion itni sawar ho gaee agar aap is thread me jitna likha ja chka he vo parh lain to aapko samhaj ajaiey gee lakin "AAP TO ME NA MANOON PE DATEY HOEY HAIN"
ye to khawab he Allah haqeeqat me kehta he k tum meree madad karo me tumharee madad karonga..............???????????
is ko kia quran se nikal do ge kionkey Tahir ul qadri ko ghalat sabit krna he tum ne.
Q3) Does Prophet SWM have worldly desire to eat and drink?
A3-Well if you consider Him Human then as a human He has ,he liked dates(khajoor) ,milk ,meat ,kaddu sweat dish.I don't know why have you asked such a baseless question.
straight forward jawab he jin cheezo ka main ne zikr kia he kaho k vo Huzur s.a.w ko pasand nhi thee ja kr koi evidence le kr ao.phir me b evidence lata ho iskey favour main.
Mera tum se jawabi sawal he kia tum hzur s.a.w ko insan nhi mantey???????
Q4) In His SWM life He SWM lead a life with two two stones tied on His SWM stomach, and now He SWM needs food to eat?
A4-that is stupid reason you are giving ..........i can only laugh at it.......if you have a proof that he never eat in his life(which you will never find) then you can object on this part ,otherwise i have explained it in point 3.
Me challenge krta hoon ye baat sabit krdo k Huzur s.a.w ne sari zindagi do/2 pathar pait pe baandh kr guzari sari zindagi lagey raho sabit nhi kr sako gey.jhoot ki b koi hadd hotey ha.
Aalim fazil mian ye b kisi gazwah ka vakia he sari zindagi ka nhi.
vo jo grade 5 me tumhain parhata tha tumhara aakhri teacher vo b tumhara ye sawal sun k panchvien ka certificate vapis le le ga.
Q5) Why did Muhammad SWM came to Pakistan, when it is reported in sahi hadeet that who so ever recite Darood on Him SWM it is taken to HIM SWM.
A5-Well if thats your argument then why you think that Allah is hazir nazir as wahi was brought by Jebraiel..........?
And how can you relate the event that happened at Koh E toor ........?
the hadyt is still valid it does not contradict with the hadyt.................you forget its a dream.
where in the hadyt it says that no pakistani can see Him in his dream.???????
where in hadyt it is written that in a dream He cannot go to pakistan????????
kia tum khuda bun gaiey ho jo apni taraf se verdict de rahey ho hadyt me to koiee aisee baat nhi
I was trying to be simple in my question, fully Knowing your ability that what you will reply. Let me rephrase it in more simple language.
Doosro ki fikr na kro i am using computer since 1992 and internet since 1995.........
jesey koi dehati suit pehn leta he to apney aap ko koi toup samhajna shuru kr deta he lagta he k kisi paindo ne 5 jamatain parh hi lee hain jo baraa itra raha he apni taleem pe.
Does Muhammad SWM needs an aeroplane to come to Pakistan and go back to Madina, after His SWM Death.And on top of that He SWM needs to buy air tickets, and that too through Tahir Qadri.
Bhai merey to kia khwaab main jahaz pe baithney pe pabandi he???????????
Ya kisi deobandi ne fatwa diya hoa he k khwab me jahaz ka safar krna haram he??????
Ya kisi deo..... ne fatwa de diya he k jo log dunya se parda farma gaiey hain vo khwab me nhi asaktey?????????????
Ya kisi ne ban lagaya hoa he k kisi ko khwab me pakistan atey hoey daikhna mana he????????
Khwab me kia ticket le k dena kufr he???????????
kis cheez pe aiteraaz he tumhain...................tumhain sirf tahirul qadri se bughz he ye khwab tumhain aya hota to phir jaiz tha.
ye btao k kia tum plan kr k khwab daikhtey ho k ye daikhna he ye nhi daikhna khwab he koi movie nhi k drictor apni marzi se script change kr raha he????????
How can He SWM needs worldly things as food and shelter after HIS SWM death. Than if He SWM needs those things after HIS SWM death what about other things that humans beings require after eating and drinking the call for nature.
zara tameez se jb Huzur s.a.w k barey me guftagu kia kro to zuban sambhal k guftagu kia kro.................tumharey andr itna gand hi agar bhara hoa he to buktey raho tahir ul qadri pr lakin Huzur s.a.w k barey main aisee batain na likhtey hoey sharam anee chahey tumhain...........
shayad umer ziada ho gaee he isliaey bhool jatey ho ye khwab ka vakia he haqeeqat nhi..............jo itna heran pareshan ho rahey ho.
Tahir Qadri can say all these things about his dreams while sitting in the Majilis of JAAHILS. And please for God sake don’t send me these videos, I have been listening him live when you were not even born, so I know Tahir Sahib very well. I know what agenda he is working on.
haan tum jesey jahil b hotey hain mehfil main................jahiloon ko ye b masla hota he k vo apney aap ko bara parha likha or daana samhatey hain,Abu jehl b aisa hi tha vo b doosro ko jahil samhajta tha.............
aalim fazil sahab mubarik ho aap pehley nikal aiey baher bara teer maar lia aap ne.
uska to pata nhi lakin aapka agenda tahir ul qadri k khilaaf he chahey apna eeman hi kion na jaey lakin tahir ul qadri bach k na jaey..........
Regarding your Aik sawal, come on man grow up, go type it on google and you will get the answer. That’s why I never quote any Hadees because I know what Cut and Paste is going on in this forum. More over I did my grade 5 in 1976 or so. So this question seems much higher than my level.
best way to avoid a question kion google pe search krtey ho.......phir Allah ko b google pe hi dhoond lo.............
level mashallah aapkey sawalo se lagta he k grade 5 k exam b aapki jaga kisi ore ne hi diya ho ga.
Brother apart from all these, my humble request to you is study the deen yourself, don’t follow blindly to your peer, your leader. Allah has given you brain and Allah commands us in the Quran that one must contemplate into my creation and try to unfold it. See where the world is heading to. Your salvation lies in your own hand, and not in your peers hand. As Prophet Muhammad SWM in His SWM last days addressed in Masjid Nabawi, while HIS SWM daughter and (AUNT) Pophi were listening to it. He SWM said let my Daughter and Pophi know that Muhammad SWM will not be of any help to them, but their own good deeds will save them on the day of judgement. ( Allah knows the best) Read your self the history of Islam, see who did what for the Islam. Read every thing with open mind, and InshAllah Allah will guide you as Allah guided me. Want to share your thoughts with me, PM me and we can discuss. May Allah protect you and entire Ummah from all evils.
Well brother you should have used this tone but...........ok
I don't follow anyone blindly and i also do not consider myself an aalim ,and i believe that inventing a wheel again and again will not make us inteligent it will only show our foolishness.
I am a researcher and i know that in any field of knowledge if you want to have some research that first thing you need to know is that what work has already been done in that field and what prominent personalities are doing or have done research in this field.after studying them all then you are able to do some research work.
its the most stupid way that anybody comes up and he consults no one in that field and says that he is doing research in that field.
salvation agar own hand me hotee to Nabi bhaijne ki koi zaroorat nhi thee.
kafiro ko b salvation miltee.abu- jehl shayad dunyavi ilm k lihaaz se bara parha likha tha quresh k log us se mashvarey lia krtey they lakin uskey mukabley main hazrat bilal habshi r.a. hain kisko kia mila ore kion mila sari dunya janteee he koi munafikat me ya bughz me chup he to konsi hidayat mangta he.
Allah ka asool kal b vohi tha aaj b vohi he................
Aik dunyavi insaan k ilm ki kia hasiat ho gee Allah k ilm k samney ???
uski likhee hoee kitaab ko parhney k liaey hm aik ustad k paas jatey hain k vo hmain samjhaey k iska kia matlab he ore likhney vala kia btana chahta he.............
ajeeb baat he Kainaat k malik ,jiskey ilm be hisaab uski kitaab k liaey aap keh rahey hain k kisi se rehnumaiee na lo khud parhoo.. .................intehaiee foolish mashwara he.
Quran me hi likha hoa he k is se kaie hidayat paieengy or kaee gumraah hongey............aik bohut bara reason to main ooper bta chuka.
And FYI i have read all these controversal issues in between different sects of islam.
the main reason for these difference is that we do not take it as an acadmic discussion in a positive way but our approach is only to target other personality or sect.
same behaviour is shown by you you have no issue about the dreams about the Holy Prophet s.a.w you are not discussing that your only focus is targeting particular personality and a particular sect.
such discussions will only increase the differences bcs aim is not knowledge aim is defaming personality or a sect.
i have read many such stories and i know many such points with references from their books but in responce to your allegations i did not target a sect or a personality my approach was only to discuss the valedity of the questions in a logical way.