Saudi Govt. Accept Mistake-Eid Ul Fitr Was Declared On The Wrong Day

Status
Not open for further replies.

makdaone

Councller (250+ posts)
Saudi government admitted there's been a mistake about the correct day of Id Al Fitr this year(2011). This occured due to misunderstanding of a particular phenomenon cause by planet Saturnus as before happened a couple of years ago caused by planet Mercurius. What it thought to be Hilal(new moon) is actually not. The Government gave order to the people and citizen of Saudi Kingdom to qodlo fasting day of one day because Ied Al-Fitr supposed to be on August 31/2011 and not on August 30/2011. As also there's news that Saudi Government will pay Kafarah money 1 Billion reyal for this mistake. http://www.qatarliving.com/node/2066944#ixzz1WvMb7RAJ

there is no such news here you just trying to speared fitna over here
 

biomat

Minister (2k+ posts)
I believe that Saudis plan whole year before based on astronomical data.
Thats why whole muslim ummah celebrate EID on different days..
I have moon sighting site which have nearly 40 years of data from all over the world & alhumdulillah PAKISTAN follow it more accurately..
 

Mysticreed

Banned
Re: Scientist threatened in Saudia for doubting Eid moon sighting

bhai shahb ye web side bhi Dallas Texas.........ki ID HE # 50.22.195.239http://www.almasryalyoum.com/en/node/491496[/QUO

Bhai sahab mein ne kab kaha ke yeh jupiter ki website hai ??????????????? Try to refute the news rather than raising a nonsense issue !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Yaar seedha seedha kaho you don't have any logical explanation !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

What about Arab news link that I posted above ????????? kahin woh mars ki to nahi ???????????????? lol lol

And what about these websites below ??????????????

http://www.kuwaitnews.com/index.php...288&catid=34&Itemid=144#.Tl7JLZi3jdO.facebook

http://www.alarabiya.net/articles/2011/08/31/164873.html
 

Mysticreed

Banned
Re: Scientist threatened in Saudia for doubting Eid moon sighting

bhai shahb ye web side bhi Dallas Texas.........ki ID HE # 50.22.195.239http://www.almasryalyoum.com/en/node/491496

Bhai sahab mein ne kab kaha ke yeh jupiter ki website hai ??????????????? Try to refute the news rather than raising a nonsense issue !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Yaar seedha seedha kaho you don't have any logical explanation !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

What about Arab news link that I posted above ????????? kahin woh mars ki to nahi ???????????????? lol lol

And what about these websites below ??????????????

http://www.kuwaitnews.com/index.php?...i3jdO.facebook

http://www.alarabiya.net/articles/20...31/164873.html
 

biomat

Minister (2k+ posts)
Re: Scientist threatened in Saudia for doubting Eid moon sighting

1432shw_8-29-2011.gif
 

famamdani

Minister (2k+ posts)
Re: Scientist threatened in Saudia for doubting Eid moon sighting

Bhai sahab mein ne kab kaha ke yeh jupiter ki website hai ??????????????? Try to refute the news rather than raising a nonsense issue !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Yaar seedha seedha kaho you don't have any logical explanation !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

What about Arab news link that I posted above ????????? kahin woh mars ki to nahi ???????????????? lol lol

And what about these websites below ??????????????

http://www.kuwaitnews.com/index.php?...i3jdO.facebook

http://www.alarabiya.net/articles/20...31/164873.html


bhai shahb..............aap ne kuwaitnews ka article paraha pehle tou is ka mahasil kia nikla............................unhone koi final decission nahi diya balke end me unhone suggetion dia he saudi hakomat ko ke woh chand dekhne ke system ko well update technology ke saath ikhtiar kare tou muslim duniya ke liye better result mil sakta he..............................

www.alarabiya.net web side from Italy.......................:lol::lol::angry_smile::angry_smile:...............which is releible pls explain us.................and direct from saudia have you some information ............................please
www.kuwaitnews.com from
Ort der IP-Adresse
50.23.34.201:
Dallas in United States.
 
Last edited:

Mysticreed

Banned
Re: Scientist threatened in Saudia for doubting Eid moon sighting

bhai shahb..............aap ne kuwaitnews ka article paraha pehle tou is ka mahasil kia nikla............................unhone koi final decission nahi diya balke end me unhone suggetion dia he saudi hakomat ko ke woh chand dekhne ke system ko well update technology ke saath ikhtiar kare tou muslim duniya ke liye better result mil sakta he..............................

Bhai sahab mein ne kab yeh kaha jo aap ne samjha ?????????????? Newspapers are not supposed to give verdicts but present the news. The astronomers of Saudia have even challenged the decision of the Saudi mullas concerning the moon sighting date !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Poor Saudi mullas and poor souls who follow them !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 

famamdani

Minister (2k+ posts)
Re: Scientist threatened in Saudia for doubting Eid moon sighting

Bhai sahab mein ne kab yeh kaha jo aap ne samjha ?????????????? Newspapers are not supposed to give verdicts but present the news. The astronomers of Saudia have even challenged the decision of the Saudi mullas concerning the moon sighting date !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Poor Saudi mullas and poor souls who follow them !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

aur aap apne aap per kub rehm famae gain....................aap ne jo teen web ID as refrence qout ki he wo sari web show UAE aur GULF...........ki bazahir lagti hain lekin sub ki sub UK.Italy.texas Dallas se control ho rahi hain..............ab faisla aap ne karna he ........................................MAZA AYA.......................
 

famamdani

Minister (2k+ posts)
Re: Scientist threatened in Saudia for doubting Eid moon sighting

Bhai sahab mein ne kab kaha ke yeh jupiter ki website hai ??????????????? Try to refute the news rather than raising a nonsense issue !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Yaar seedha seedha kaho you don't have any logical explanation !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

What about Arab news link that I posted above ????????? kahin woh mars ki to nahi ???????????????? lol lol

And what about these websites below ??????????????

http://www.kuwaitnews.com/index.php?...i3jdO.facebook

http://www.alarabiya.net/articles/20...31/164873.html


is ka matlab he agar jupiter se web side deal ho rahi ho to woh aap ke qabil e etabar nahi hogi................??????

and kuwait news controled from Dellas ..............
and arabiya controled from Italy...................
 

Mysticreed

Banned
Re: Scientist threatened in Saudia for doubting Eid moon sighting

aur aap apne aap per kub rehm famae gain....................aap ne jo teen web ID as refrence qout ki he wo sari web show UAE aur GULF...........ki bazahir lagti hain lekin sub ki sub UK.Italy.texas Dallas se control ho rahi hain..............ab faisla aap ne karna he ........................................MAZA AYA.......................

Dude I know you will remain a Saud mulla slave. I have never claimed any of the websites that I posted to be Saudi in origin. All I said that it has been posted in many news websites. Saudi government will never allow to post any news that goes against them in this manner in their news papers. Their media is controlled. Guardian is a well known newspaper of UK. It has also posted the news and quoted the astronomers of Saudia. The way forward for Saudia is to sue all these news websites since you claim the news to be false. Why isn't Saudia sueing these websites including Guardian ??????????????????

Fars news is posted from Tehran, Iran. It is a good chance for the Saudis to sue them as well and shut their mouths once for all !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Dude this is 21st century not 18th century where you people could deviate the attention and shout foul play. Kindly go ahead and sue all these news websites !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I quote Guardian below

Maged Abou Zahra, president of the Jeddah Astronomical Society, told the Egyptian paper al-Shorouk: "The sighting of a new moon would have simply been impossible." http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/sep/05/astronomers-query-ramadan-end
 
Last edited:

Mysticreed

Banned
Re: Scientist threatened in Saudia for doubting Eid moon sighting

is ka matlab he agar jupiter se web side deal ho rahi ho to woh aap ke qabil e etabar nahi hogi................??????

and kuwait news controled from Dellas ..............
and arabiya controled from Italy...................

Lol that's your brain level. That was a sarcastic comment !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 

famamdani

Minister (2k+ posts)
Re: Scientist threatened in Saudia for doubting Eid moon sighting

Lol that's your brain level. That was a sarcastic comment !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


aray aap tou mazaq ko dil pe lay gai...................................lagta he aap ko MAZA NAHI AYA............................
 

Mysticreed

Banned
Re: Scientist threatened in Saudia for doubting Eid moon sighting

aray aap tou mazaq ko dil pe lay gai...................................lagta he aap ko MAZA NAHI AYA............................

Lol I can see that !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Let's move forward as enough said by me on that one !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The Fatwa of Sheikh Abdal Aziz bin Baz:

http://www.hilalcommittee.com/fatwas/binbazfatwa.html

The Fatwa of Sheikh Saleh bin Uthaymeen

http://www.hilalcommittee.com/fatwas/fatwa2.html

both of these scholars clearly state that a Saudi moonsighting is not binding on other countries, in fact they go so far as to say that each country to establish a local sighting


 

Mysticreed

Banned
The news of astronomers of Gulf complaining about moonsighting isn't a new issue. It has happened in the recent past in 2006. Remember the UAE government follows the Saudi government for Ramadan and Eid !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Ramadan 'was announced on wrong day'

Astronomers in the UAE maintain that the announcement of the beginning of Ramadan on Friday, September 22, was incorrect, and that it should have in fact been announced two days later.

http://gulfnews.com/news/gulf/uae/general/ramadan-was-announced-on-wrong-day-1.259126
 
Last edited:

famamdani

Minister (2k+ posts)
Re: Scientist threatened in Saudia for doubting Eid moon sighting

Lol I can see that !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Let's move forward as enough said by me on that one !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The Fatwa of Sheikh Abdal Aziz bin Baz:

http://www.hilalcommittee.com/fatwas/binbazfatwa.html

The Fatwa of Sheikh Saleh bin Uthaymeen

http://www.hilalcommittee.com/fatwas/fatwa2.html

both of these scholars clearly state that a Saudi moonsighting is not binding on other countries, in fact they go so far as to say that each country to establish a local sighting



thats mean every country make eid on own sighting.................its ok

196 eid in per year..........................................every country make his own moon local sighting................tou jhagra koun kar raha he............................saudia walon ne tou kisi kou gun point pe le kar majboor nahi kia ke aaj hi eid manao.............????????
 

Mysticreed

Banned
Re: Scientist threatened in Saudia for doubting Eid moon sighting

thats mean every country make eid on own sighting.................its ok

196 eid in per year..........................................every country make his own moon local sighting................tou jhagra koun kar raha he............................saudia walon ne tou kisi kou gun point pe le kar majboor nahi kia ke aaj hi eid manao.............????????

You need to question the Najdi mullas for this fatwa. I am in no way responsible for it. Pakistan's version is simple and clear that we use the help of scientific technology combined with traditional methods to announce Eid and other months !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top