Re: The main contributions of ghulam ahmed parwez to islam and muslims
Dear brother Abdullah, understanding of things has great deal to do with language but by language I do not mean bread and butter language of illiterate and ignorant people. Parwez sb's understanding of the quran is not due to mere arabic language but the knowledge he had about things the quran is talking about. Tell me if I tell you to do something in the language you speak will you be able to do it? The answer is no. Ask yourself, why a few years old kid cannot do things that you can even though you both talk in same language? This is why no one who has no idea what the quran is talking about has the right to be critical of a person who knows what is being said. To be critical of anyone one must possess the needed knowledge and know how. An arab child is as clueless about the quran as an english or urdu speaking child. You tell an english speaking kid make me a cup of tea, he will not be able to do it and the results will be the same with your own child because something a person never known or experienced is out of his reach.
This is why we have ended up stupid because we do not think and give authority to illiterate and ignorant people to lead us and we worship them. If we want to do better then we must realise these very basic facts.
I have not come across anyone who understands how arabic language works. Not even an arab. Go and ask them yourself and find out. Don't be impressed by very long titles people use for each other to show how greatly learned they are but if you get in to nitty gritty of things you will soon come to know that it is all hot air.
When I say the quran is a great book I prove it by my arguments, which hardly anyone else has done here. I explained the criterion for proof and proving and then showed how the quran proves to be word of God.
All I see here is aimless criticism by mullah followers closed minded people who know ought about the quran. If we keep following mullahs then we will remain as ignorant and foolish as we have been for centuries. We will have no self respect nor respect by other in the world. If we are looking for dignity it lies not in lying under mullahs but in learning the quran properly.
So my dear brother please be kind enough to reflect on your make beliefs and see how hollow they are. It is all because there is no basis for such beliefs in the quran otherwise people would have challenged me and proven me wrong long ago. They just believe things because they have been told by their mullahs that if you do not say you believe things the way we tell you then you are not a muslim. We need to disregard such hollow approach to islam and quran. Quran is based upon solid criterion and it provides solid foundation for our existence. Rest is all mullah worship which we must avoid if we wish to be successful both in this life and the next.
All I can do is pray for all of us human being to become enlightened.
regards and all the best.
to believe meaning of a sentence written in a language that is not my first language i will perefer people of that language to understand the meaning
i will not take workds of GAP who have nothing to do with that language.
in language established fact can be verified by the people of that language not others
Dear brother Abdullah, understanding of things has great deal to do with language but by language I do not mean bread and butter language of illiterate and ignorant people. Parwez sb's understanding of the quran is not due to mere arabic language but the knowledge he had about things the quran is talking about. Tell me if I tell you to do something in the language you speak will you be able to do it? The answer is no. Ask yourself, why a few years old kid cannot do things that you can even though you both talk in same language? This is why no one who has no idea what the quran is talking about has the right to be critical of a person who knows what is being said. To be critical of anyone one must possess the needed knowledge and know how. An arab child is as clueless about the quran as an english or urdu speaking child. You tell an english speaking kid make me a cup of tea, he will not be able to do it and the results will be the same with your own child because something a person never known or experienced is out of his reach.
This is why we have ended up stupid because we do not think and give authority to illiterate and ignorant people to lead us and we worship them. If we want to do better then we must realise these very basic facts.
I have not come across anyone who understands how arabic language works. Not even an arab. Go and ask them yourself and find out. Don't be impressed by very long titles people use for each other to show how greatly learned they are but if you get in to nitty gritty of things you will soon come to know that it is all hot air.
When I say the quran is a great book I prove it by my arguments, which hardly anyone else has done here. I explained the criterion for proof and proving and then showed how the quran proves to be word of God.
All I see here is aimless criticism by mullah followers closed minded people who know ought about the quran. If we keep following mullahs then we will remain as ignorant and foolish as we have been for centuries. We will have no self respect nor respect by other in the world. If we are looking for dignity it lies not in lying under mullahs but in learning the quran properly.
So my dear brother please be kind enough to reflect on your make beliefs and see how hollow they are. It is all because there is no basis for such beliefs in the quran otherwise people would have challenged me and proven me wrong long ago. They just believe things because they have been told by their mullahs that if you do not say you believe things the way we tell you then you are not a muslim. We need to disregard such hollow approach to islam and quran. Quran is based upon solid criterion and it provides solid foundation for our existence. Rest is all mullah worship which we must avoid if we wish to be successful both in this life and the next.
All I can do is pray for all of us human being to become enlightened.
regards and all the best.
Last edited: