You are saying, prophet Muhammad prohibited writing of hadees , which is written in a hadees.It is documented in several hadith books that the Prophet prohibited the scribing of anything from him except the Quran. Also, there are reports that his ‘rightly guided successors’ banned and burnt hadith materials as they tried to prevent the creation of secondary authorities next to the Quran. This specific prohibition seems to be evidenced by the historical data, e.g. lack of any authoritative hadith book during the first few generations of Muslims.
should become a rapper, it would pay,You are saying, prophet Muhammad prohibited writing of hadees , which is written in a hadees.
Don't you think the above sentence is erroneous in logic ? If there was no hadees about hadees prohibition, we wouldn't have found out Prophet Muhammad prohibited writing of Hadees .
Also Quran says to follow Prophet Muhammad, how would we follow him from Quran only ?
he is probably munkir-e-hadith. These people are not muslims as they deny and do not believe in a basic pillar of islam. It is very similar to saying " Bhai May Allah ko to manta houn per Rasool ko nahi"You are saying, prophet Muhammad prohibited writing of hadees , which is written in a hadees.
Don't you think the above sentence is erroneous in logic ? If there was no hadees about hadees prohibition, we wouldn't have found out Prophet Muhammad prohibited writing of Hadees .
Also Quran says to follow Prophet Muhammad, how would we follow him from Quran only ?
Bhai ub yeh buhut agay berh gaye hein. Some of their other follies are:قرآن مکمل ہے، منکرین حدیث ان کے خناس کو درست ثابت کرنے کے چکر میں انکار قرآن بھی کر دیتے ہیں۔
Agreed !he is probably munkir-e-hadith. These people are not muslims as they deny and do not believe in a basic pillar of islam. It is very similar to saying " Bhai May Allah ko to manta houn per Rasool ko nahi"
Basically a Kafir!
no you fuck your own mom/sister , i am not available and not interested.fuck you
So easy to declare your fellow Muslim brother KafirBasically a Kafir!
your level of mind set.no you fuck your own mom/sister , i am not available and not interested.
So true bhai, I am totally with u on that. Her koi internet per aaker part time online Prophet bana howa hay Aaj kal. Jo baat na sahaba nay ke na tabaa nay kee wo yeh ham ko aker bata rahe hein kay jee Hadith nahi hay, kal ko bulein kay Allah bhee nahi or Angels bhee nahi!Internet is full of bastards like him don't pay attention to their utter BS. we know what we are and we believe in it firmly. its bn a long practice of screwed up mind like him to create and ambiguity about Rasoolullah ( Sallallah ho aleh wasallam) among believers. so DON"T listen to these crappy nutts.
Anybody who does not believe in basic pillars of Islam is a kafir and there is nothing wrong with your choice of not accepting it, your choice but then do not force your inclusion in Islam. Islam is a an ideology if u do not follow it then u r not a muslim. Period!So easy to declare your fellow Muslim brother Kafir
No it's a religion of 2 billion people with zero copyrightsIslam is a an ideology
CHose meray yaar @===D tuje pesay mila ga!my mother is Pakistan, so puck you 3rd time
No we are not declaring him just pointing out the fact that Munkir Hadith is Kafir. which is right; beside we are not qualified to declare anybody anything it is scholar's job.So easy to declare your fellow Muslim brother Kafir
Hadith is not basic tenant of IslamA man who does not believe in Hadith ( a basic tenant of Islam) is not a muslim.