Question For Qadiyanis
- Thread starter Abdul Allah
- Start date
- Status
TechWarrior
MPA (400+ posts)
Question to Qadiyanis
Dear Qadiyanis,
Please explain me the following
If you believe that ISA A.S died at the age of 120 then how can he be a messiah? Messiah needs to fulfill his job before he die, he need to save people. Jews believed that ISA A.S was not a Messiah so if Hazrat ISA A.S died before saving people this means he is not a Messiah (Naozobillah) and Jews were right in crucifying him. On Top of that you people Believe that Ghulam Ahmad was also a Messiah and ISA A.S and he also died without saving anoyone.
The following are the beliefs from diff religions
Christians Belief: Messiah came and saved them by sacrificing his blood.
Muslims Belief: Messiah came, survived Crucifixion and raised up alive (because he is messiah he cannot die before saving people), now Muslim waiting for his second coming to be saved.
Jews Belief: waiting for messiah to save them
Above all making sense, but what Qadiyaniyat is presenting the picture of messiah seems illogical.
What is the messiah and his role, please answer me that? How can messiah die 2 times and that too without doing his job?
Dear Qadiyanis,
Please explain me the following
If you believe that ISA A.S died at the age of 120 then how can he be a messiah? Messiah needs to fulfill his job before he die, he need to save people. Jews believed that ISA A.S was not a Messiah so if Hazrat ISA A.S died before saving people this means he is not a Messiah (Naozobillah) and Jews were right in crucifying him. On Top of that you people Believe that Ghulam Ahmad was also a Messiah and ISA A.S and he also died without saving anoyone.
The following are the beliefs from diff religions
Christians Belief: Messiah came and saved them by sacrificing his blood.
Muslims Belief: Messiah came, survived Crucifixion and raised up alive (because he is messiah he cannot die before saving people), now Muslim waiting for his second coming to be saved.
Jews Belief: waiting for messiah to save them
Above all making sense, but what Qadiyaniyat is presenting the picture of messiah seems illogical.
What is the messiah and his role, please answer me that? How can messiah die 2 times and that too without doing his job?
Last edited:
- Status
