Emotional rhetoric aside, some fundamental questions for PTIians, if someone care to think and answer in a logical way. Its easy to sputter obscenities as it does not take much thinking and effort. But in real life its best to consider all possible scenarios, work out all ifs and buts, before embarking on any mission.
So some fundamental questions about Nov 30 are as follows:
1- whats the ultimate objective and goal of Nov 30 expedition?
2- how that objective is going to be achieved?
3- what if projected number of people are not gathered? Where does it go from there?
4- even if projected number of people are gathered, then what?
5- does PTI plan to invade parliament house and PM house? But IK is saying it will be peaceful?
6- even if PTI invade parliament and PM house then what are they going to do after that? Burn them or occupy them?
7- even if PTI burn or occupy parliament and PM house, how the change will come?
8- because its clear that PM is going to resign so whats the plan?
9- if above violence does occur then people's sympathies will turn in govt favor and PTI will loose any moral standing
10- is PTI expecting army to intervene?
11- even if army intervene, they will not hand over govt to PTI
12- so PTI may say that army will hold new elections. But the track record so far indicates that if army comes then they wont leave before 10 years.
13- ok lets assume that army holds new elections within few months, then those elections will be held under same rules and regulations as of last elections. So how things will change for PTI?
14- some might say army will install a govt of technocrats. If so then under which constitution and law? What will be the legitimacy of any actions taken by such technocrat govt. Even military dictators need pseudo elected assemblies to make laws
Its easy to say 'hum sub ki gardaney utar dein gay' but think with a sane mind what are the practical possibilities? What's the next step after Nov 30? I asked similar questions before aug 14 dharna and the only answer i got was we trust that IK will have a plan. Well, as it tuned out IK did not have plan ever for the first night as after a couple of speeches he retreated back to the comforts of bani gala. Did you ask these questions of PTI leadership before committing yourself? If not, then doesnt it make you a blind follower as well?
So some fundamental questions about Nov 30 are as follows:
1- whats the ultimate objective and goal of Nov 30 expedition?
2- how that objective is going to be achieved?
3- what if projected number of people are not gathered? Where does it go from there?
4- even if projected number of people are gathered, then what?
5- does PTI plan to invade parliament house and PM house? But IK is saying it will be peaceful?
6- even if PTI invade parliament and PM house then what are they going to do after that? Burn them or occupy them?
7- even if PTI burn or occupy parliament and PM house, how the change will come?
8- because its clear that PM is going to resign so whats the plan?
9- if above violence does occur then people's sympathies will turn in govt favor and PTI will loose any moral standing
10- is PTI expecting army to intervene?
11- even if army intervene, they will not hand over govt to PTI
12- so PTI may say that army will hold new elections. But the track record so far indicates that if army comes then they wont leave before 10 years.
13- ok lets assume that army holds new elections within few months, then those elections will be held under same rules and regulations as of last elections. So how things will change for PTI?
14- some might say army will install a govt of technocrats. If so then under which constitution and law? What will be the legitimacy of any actions taken by such technocrat govt. Even military dictators need pseudo elected assemblies to make laws
Its easy to say 'hum sub ki gardaney utar dein gay' but think with a sane mind what are the practical possibilities? What's the next step after Nov 30? I asked similar questions before aug 14 dharna and the only answer i got was we trust that IK will have a plan. Well, as it tuned out IK did not have plan ever for the first night as after a couple of speeches he retreated back to the comforts of bani gala. Did you ask these questions of PTI leadership before committing yourself? If not, then doesnt it make you a blind follower as well?