Re: Untold wording of Quaid e Azam about Khilafat by Dr.Israr Ahmed
یار،جھوٹ اور من گھڑت مولویوں کی بھی اللہ کے ہاں ضرور پکڑ ہوگی۔وہی روایات کے ذریعے کچھ کا کچھ بنا دینا۔ساری عمر گنوادی اور موت سے دو دن پہلے خلافت یاد آ رہی ہے۔کوئی اس گپی سے پوچھے کہ اگرجناح خلافت کے اتنے ہی مداح تھے تو خلافت موومنٹ میں حصہ کیوں نہیں لیا؟اس وقت گھر میں کیوں بیٹھے رہے؟صرف اس لئے کہ ترکی کی خلافت انگریز نے ختم کی تھی اورسارے ہندوستان میں اس کا ردعمل ہوا تھا۔مشہور تحریک خلافت،جس کے روح رواں مولانا محمدعلی جوھر اورمولانا شوکت علی تھے حتی یہ کہ گاندھی نے بھی مسلمانوں سے اظہار یکجہتی کے لیئے اس میں حصہ لیا تھا۔اس وقت کیا ہوگیا تھا جناح صاحب کو؟کیوں تحریک خلافت کی مخالفت کی تھی؟کیا انگریز کو خوش کرنے کیلئے؟اب اسرار احمد صاحب کو ایک ڈائیری ملی ہے اور کہانی بیان ہو رہی ہے۔ساری زندگی جناح نے مسلمانوں والا کوئی کام نہیں کیا۔ کیا واسطہ ان کا خلافت سے؟زیادہ مت کہلواؤ۔اس ملک میں سچ بولنا سب سے بڑا جرم ہے۔جہاں مولوی صرف واہ واہ کروانے کیلئے جھوٹ بول رہے ہوں وہاں یہی حشر ہوگا جو اس ملک کا ہو رہا ہے۔
Dear mrbaig, jinnah's understanding of the quran was not that of a mulla but of a lawyer. He did not believe in islam based on make beliefs. Make belief islam is a dogmatic creed and ritualism based islam. His understanding of islamic concepts was not there in mullas or masses. The same is true about sir seyyid ahemad khan, iqbal and g a parwez and many many more through out history.
The quran is the constitution for mankind not a book for khatam drood as is usual amongst mullas and masses. Unless one understand this difference one cannot know islam of jinnah.
Coming to two nation theory, it is not what masses make of it but a an idea about providing the muslim nation with a nest egg or starting point to develop from. There is a huge difference between dividing people on basis of religion on negative basis and grouping up a people under a banner on positive basis as a pilot project for the whole humanity. That is what the prophet did in state of madinah.
Pilot projects are experimental setups at a small scale to see if things will work and if they do then such projects become norm at a wider scale. It is like a tribe tribe comes up with an idea of business and sets up a few people from amongst itself and if they are successful then idea could be taken up by the rest as well.
To think like jinnah or sir seyyid or iqbal one needs a lot bigger mind. I am surprised at these peoples' foresight and farsightedness. Unfortunately, when it comes to islam, we cannot avoid mullas and the masses that follow them due to lack of education and critical thought. It took me nearly six decades to realise where these people were coming from.
It is because when you are born in a muslim family, you are fed with islam of mullas and then it takes ages to come out of that frame of thought and then to rediscover real islam and the real world. I have been there so I know what is going on but then it will take me yet more time to express what I have learned in my life for others.
Mawdudi sb mostly stuck to inherited islamic concepts. Anywhere he went off the track mullas were standing on his head with big sticks. He had no idea of what jinnah stood for that is why he opposed when did that. Hindus misunderstood due to mullas and muslim masses. The concept could not be clarified because that would have killed the project. It is like father takes his children somewhere for their benefit but does not explain to them because they cannot understand so he takes them anyway hoping when they grow up they will become aware of it.
When sir seyyid told mullas to stay away from make beliefs what was reaction? When mawdudi told people some things were shirk what was reaction?
This is why debate on what the real islam was avoided at the time because masses and mullas both had no idea and could not understand. Any time we start discussion on islam sectarianism raises its ugly head right away.
However, now that we have a state, we need to educate people to level of these people so that they could come to realise what these people told us. This is yet a distant dream the while economic strength is not there to improve our peoples' education. So this debate is yet to be fully realised and I am very sure that given the right time and attention it will be solved.
Make beliefs are like drug addiction and they cannot be overcome that easily but little by little education by way of discussions will bring some relief till we have what is needed to get rid of all make beliefs in the name of islam.
regards and all the best
