جی کراچی کی عوام سمجھتی ہے۔ اسی لیے وہ لاکھوں کی تعداد میں متحدہ کو سپورٹ کرتی ہے۔ اسی لیے ایجنسیوں اور میڈیا کے ہزار جھوٹے الزامات کے باوجود وہ انہیں کذاب سمجھتے ہوئے ان کے جھوٹے الزامات پر کان نہیں دھرتی۔
Bibi, getting votes is not the criteria of whether you are wrong or right. Its called popular vote for a reason. If number of votes was the criteria of judging someone's guilt then you know that Sharif, Zardari, Chaudhries, Fazlurehman and in fact the members of the parliament all around get millions of votes to get elected.
Your party yourself point out to Sharifs and Zardari's corruption yet millions of people go out to vote for them and send them to the parliament and get them to rule us and you ally with them too. Its all due to votes. Its not a gauge for anything - specially in our country.
متحدہ کوئی فرشتہ نہیں ۔ اس میں جرائم ہو سکتے ہیں۔ ہم کراچی والوں کا یہی کہتا ہے کہ انہیں پکڑو چاہے یہ الطاف حسین ہی کیوں نہ ہو۔۔۔۔ لیکن جب رینجرز والے فقط اپنے تعصب کے باعث "ہزاروں" جھوٹے مقدمات بنائیں اور خود کو قانون سے بالاتر سمجھیں، تو پھر ایسے رینجرز اور انکی ریاستی دہشتگردی کو ہم کراچی والوں کا دور سے سلام۔
کراچی کی ضرورت ایک "منصفانہ آپریشن" تھی، ایک تعصب زدہ ریاستی دہشتگرد آپریشن نہیں۔
We all know that the military forces and even the police use high-handed tactics when they are dealing with what they think are the targets. But its okay for you guys when they do that in FATA and in other parts of the country and in fact you egg them on but when it comes to Karachi it becomes an international issue.
اور کیا آپ کو علم ہے کہ مشرف صاحب کے 8 سالہ دور میں بغیر کسی آپریشن کے ہی کراچی میں جرائم کی سطح آج رینجرز کے اس 2 سالہ آپریشن کی جرائم کی سطح سے کم تھی؟ آج کراچی میں 2 سال آپریشن کرنے کے باوجود رینجرز اتنی روشنیاں نہیں لا سکے جتنا کہ مشرف دور میں بغیر کسی آپریشن کے جلتی تھیں۔
A military dictator is effectively a king. He can do what he wants to and most people don't dare question his authority. In Musharraf's days you guys were basically the judge, jury and executioners. You had a free reign to rule the urban centers. Musharraf had an arrangement where he gave the rural sindh to an imbecile like arbab rahim and handed you guys the urban centers of karachi and hyderabad and then threw a lot of cash at MK to go work and got him all the help and resources that he needed.
What Altaf hussain is complaining about now - that people committed corruption or made a lot of money didn't happen in just these last 6-7 years. It started back in early 2000s. Lot of people started making a lot of money because they used MQM's name and clout durng the musharraf regime to get a free hand to do what they wanted to do.
Altaf himself has pointed out china cutting and land grabbing by his own party members. The problem happened when musharraf went ta ta and all the other criminal elements in other political parties saw an opening to make some money too and thats when we had some of the bloodiest times in Karachi where you guys basically fought turf wars with similar criminal elements in ANP and PPP. It was not an ethnic fight or fight for anyones rights. It was a fight over divvying up the loot.
ہم آپریشن کے خلاف نہیں۔ مگر ہم ریاستی دہشتگردی کے خلاف ہیں۔ ۔۔۔۔ یہ وہ بات ہے جو ہماری قوم والے نہیں سمجھ پا رہے ہیں۔ پوری 90 کی دہائی میں وہ یہ بات نہ سمجھ پائے، اور افسوس کہ آج بھی وہ یہ سمجھنے سے قاصر ہیں۔
If this is state sponsored terrorism then raise your voice and make your case but the thing is that when the families from FATA were saying the same thing that along with the terrorists some innocent people were getting killed then there were not many who supported those voices. Its sad if its happening but you are wrong that this just as it was in 1990s. It is not! This is 2015 - we have come a long way. There was no news channels, no social media, no cell phone cameras, lots of ways to share information and even Rangers seem to be answerable. If they are committing excesses then highlight those with facts and evidence and I am sure that if its happening then it would stop.
I am sure that if you go to Liyari, where by some accounts around 200-300 people were killed by rangers then you would hear similar stories. Or if you go to your favorite spot, sohrab goth, then you would hear the same stories.
The other day i heard on TV that the rangers entered a house and the ladies were saying that they asked who are the speakers and if they were then they were arrested and if you spoke punjabi or sindhi or pushto then you were let go. Now this seems far fetched in this day and age but IF its widespread as you and others claim that it is then I am sure that we will see it on video but so far we have not seen anything like that reported.
